-
do
-
do
-
welcome to but the Indic Boyce
-
I'm Balram Singh the director center for
an extended their doom at dartmouth
-
and this is a collaborative program
would be in the CTB
-
and send to friend expertise at U-mass I
have
-
a my colleague the beach and I'll
joining me mid
-
our guest today newman who travel with
the president of infinity foundation
-
just published a book on being different
-
Indian talent to invest in universalism
-
he just spoke yesterday and in what city
add a comment: reef by
-
professor Francis Clooney a fire in your
city
-
to that very the present-day San today
he is kindly agreed to
-
give us some idea about his book and my
colleague save it and I am going to
-
begin
-
asking some questions I thank you so
much that testing
-
welcome mister hope they were very glad
to have you with us on
-
so your book is called being different
an Indian challenge to Western
-
universalism
-
and it's dealing with this very
controversial and very interesting topic
-
up western universalism could you define
that for our viewers are just talk a
-
little bit about what
-
sure you know Western Union each
organization has its own
-
idea of the truth of the world of
history
-
of philosophy religion ideas a law ideas
of morality
-
and no one has a claim to being the only
one of the best 10 the absolute one
-
but the West having colonize the world
and having a so much power over
-
everybody else
-
and the language of the west English
which we are speaking
-
having become sort of universal through
the institutional mechanisms controlled
-
by the Western education in media
-
in policymaking and through various
other means
-
the Western ideas have become kind of
global
-
universal so western universalism
-
is basically a term which says which
means that
-
the west's point %uh view on certain
things have become universal now
-
just like a fish might not recognize
water because so immersed in it
-
we are so immersed in western US citizen
including indians
-
that we we we might not even understand
that such a thing exists we might think
-
it is universities in israel
universalism
-
so it helps us to step out and why they
argue couple examples the chinese have
-
created a
-
a kind of conclusion universalism using
confucian thought
-
confucian ethics confucian modernity
which says basically that there is
-
another
-
another will be mater and use having
science and technology but not
-
necessarily imitating the West
-
and so why are the chinese are becoming
very industrial
-
and very progressive in in a modern
sense they don't think that they have
-
too westernized in order to do that to
the committee confucian
-
in there identity and their sense of
history and and values
-
and yet be modern at the same time a
second example is Islam
-
Islam why it hasn't achieved the same
opportunity as China
-
but Islam claim to have an alternative
worldview of everything under the Sun
-
according to an Islamic philosophy so
this is certainly a Western
-
universalism contesting that in the
Chinese universities and an islamic
-
universities and
-
to the question I was wondering is
whether there is an Indian contribution
-
to
-
this discussion on universes apps all
right to your book
-
is that a formulation what you think
that contribution yes
-
alright what would you how would you
stay up for in short message
-
well a the the the first lady at the
foreign to walk you through the logical
-
the book the first
-
thing I want to say is it's important to
assert difference
-
because difference is a principal in the
cosmos and the only way to avoid
-
differences to make people watching us
-
and to make cultures homogeneous it
requires either genocide somebody or you
-
and save somebody
-
or you could want everybody to your
point of view or those who haven't
-
already complex can
-
sought start making someone else
pretending to be someone else there's a
-
loss of diversity in any such
-
method so the alternative to this
-
loss of diversity and homogenisation
into a single universalism
-
is being different so that's what I love
my book is being different
-
that's the project at the book is to is
to explain why being different is
-
important
-
the alternative to being different is
being digested that's what I love her
-
next book
-
out be they guessed it well that sounds
unpleasant what does that and
-
well being they guessed it is 11
civilization gets digested into another
-
and loses it on identity and its own
southward sort of like
-
a Dr gets digested into a tiger and the
deer DNA disappears
-
there's not one molecule up to your DNA
left the Tiger has to break it down into
-
smaller and smaller parks
-
and each molecule of the DNA the top of
the deer has been broken into parts
-
and these are reassembled into Tigers
DNA so what survives its Tigers DNA and
-
the
-
and the Dr disappears now this has
happened to civilizations
-
the pagans contributed so much into
Christianity the Christmas tree
-
Easter lot of things came out the big
guns but the bigger themselves disappear
-
the native americans contribute so much
to Western culture
-
it's now re characterized as Western
-
its its and their Western pioneers in
Western history of all these things came
-
about
-
without even giving proper credit to the
source
-
so the digested cultures live in
-
museums they're not driving they're not
living that they've indicated of what
-
was good about them
-
and I don't want Indian civilization to
get digested into the West
-
knife in that there is a risk that might
happen because a whole lotta
-
appropriation and then we characterize
issue into the Western metaphor
-
in western framework is already
happening of our tradition
-
okay is a huge amount of stuff that has
that's a very interesting
-
are you when you have that there this
this appropriation digestion is already
-
taking place
-
do you think you could get some examples
of that kind sure you see happening
-
sure well a lot of up I right here in
the Massachusetts area
-
you have a John Cabot said who has a
trademark to
-
mindfulness meditation but actually it's
the best and the person I'm a dish in
-
which he learnt and wrote about in his
early
-
years eyes a Buddhist this system that
cannot be separated from the overall
-
philosophy of life
-
buddhism but separating it from with is
a
-
secular rising it turning it into modern
medicine getting tech trademarks and
-
patents and getting all kinds of
-
and I H Natasha health grads and so on
-
has decoupled it from its roots
-
and turn it into western thought another
one is a
-
for Benson and Harvard who took the
Transcendental Meditation up by Rishi
-
and turn it into his own spin on it call
the relaxation response trademarked it
-
and became a thriving success now the
issue with all this is that
-
while in the short term it seems to
popularize something
-
without the Indian so-called baggage
which is how the expert rationalize why
-
they're doing this
-
but in the long run you do not get the
benefit of what had been left behind
-
a whole lot of the source tradition is
left behind
-
to the nice is the tip of the iceberg
and the whole matter physics and
-
philosophy in cosmology how
-
how it has to work with the soil of a
blunt
-
cannot be left behind you cannot remove
the plant washing of the salt
-
so I'll and replanted somewhere as we
are losing something so the Indian soil
-
the routes have been logged in
-
denuded of the Indian soil and therefore
the is in the interest of
-
cross-fertilization which I agree was a
good idea
-
a lot has been left behind I don't want
people to think that I'm against
-
cross-fertilization
-
that I'm against I the merger
integration of civilizations because I
-
do believe that but it should be done in
an authentic way
-
the origin should be preserved do
regional pioneers should be respected
-
new pioneers who just went to the east
and brought all this
-
they should not be classified as the
founders
-
in Massachusetts they have alternate
medicine there is a curriculum about the
-
basin in the classes
-
and they have a course a med medical
schools on the history of a holistic
-
healing
-
now you would think that holistic
healing is one thing where they would
-
certainly advising the contribution
-
but it is all her Benson did this and
and John Cabot's then came up with that
-
and Stephen numbers came up with that
and
-
these big people who used to have gurus
who
-
learned at the feet of the Indian
masters have now abandoned those
-
and become the founding fathers of this
new size
-
in the eyes of westerners so the Indian
Ali has been digested into these new
-
westerners
-
that is therefore we either being
digested
-
or we're being different okay that'll be
interesting distinction to make and I
-
think one that a lot of us don't think
when we're exploring these alternative
-
so-called alternative traditions now I'm
very curious doctor saying as the
-
director for the Center for index
studies
-
you of course interact with a wide
variety of organizations from
-
you know that these hardcore mindfulness
an alternative therapies to groups that
-
dupe claimed to have been indigenous
Indian origin
-
to different kinds of groups and
universities that engage it is
-
issues and I just in very different ways
do you have any opinions about this
-
this phenomenon and a test in that you
see occurring how do you navigate
-
between
-
is well i i do de la to people and I i'm
-
my my senses made I have to
-
to ideas and I would like to know and
you to
-
to address them when in the course we
need to understand why
-
is this need print these people to
abandon
-
and you you alluded to the fact that
nate is perhaps
-
up and these people have to
-
look at their best and audience and
maybe there is a and
-
feeling that you know the the baggage
Indian baggage on Indian
-
connexin that has some kinda baggage and
number two is why
-
is there any natural process to have
universalism
-
eastern on mister I mean is that
universalism is this an
-
in and inevitable that you have to have
the universalism
-
so so might make my own experiences that
up with a deal with
-
nice tunes who are all done most of them
are best time
-
in my class and I find them to be buried
in me and acne I have found when I teach
-
my
-
signs have created last and i'd I even
two yet on the history of yogurt
-
and it wouldn't let me they want to know
more as to how
-
and I think this is a very important
point I to address to understand and
-
address
-
is that why these people wouldn't think
of the need
-
today have to dissociate because it
seems like a place from the end
-
generous and that's not the kid they
really deeply interested again today I
-
clear more curious to find out what else
-
it is that not being dot show I have a
theory which is also going to come out
-
as a book called The you don t
-
and in the u20 re i trace all these
people
-
in their early years they were also very
sincere do a basis here they are not
-
malicious people by the way these are
not
-
bad guys I'm not saying that bad guys
they
-
went with religion win in fact rejection
of the west
-
and really immerse themselves into the
east with
-
honesty and many of those been made the
kids doing that
-
the book being different is to answer
that very question
-
what do they run into which is so
different
-
that they have to require that come back
from you know there was how much of
-
India can they keep assimilating
-
such that the at what point to the
region boundary
-
where going for other they will lose a
sense of who they are as Westerners
-
this is something very interesting TS
eliot who was a great poet
-
a very you know already informed
Sanskrit
-
read a lot of your body sheds and not as
good as boys were influenced by
-
into thought suspect literature he
-
at at one point says that this is so
profound that sounds good
-
words are so profound that makes Western
philosophers
-
look like schoolboys who said that and
any them but later he writes
-
that in order for him to go even deeper
into it he has to forget
-
who he is in terms of being a question
or any it to just jump into it
-
forget this be conditioning and then he
says now have to ponder whether I'm
-
willing to let go and just go all the
way
-
into this tradition or whether it's
important for me to hang onto my sense
-
of identity
-
as a westerner and after contemplation
he's a very honest man he bites a very
-
honest note
-
in his diary which is publishing in one
of our books
-
he says that I've decided in order for
the
-
for me to remain a westerner I have to
draw the line how far I can go.
-
so that's a u-turn moment a call that
the YouTube moment
-
meeting his reach the Proteas the age of
how much he can digest
-
how much you can accept of the Indian
stuff up
-
because there is a fear of losing his
sense of where
-
so the i do. being a westerner and this
lineage
-
his bloodline up being a westerner and
this grand sense of history
-
is an obstacle in going beyond a certain
point
-
so they're trying to remain the
Westerner in them
-
even those who admit that there's no
more wasted we are global and we are one
-
but deep inside there is something
-
that they want to hang onto and they
want to
-
have that side by side with the new
knowledge to getting from the east
-
and there is a tension between these two
so at that point the
-
that's the age which this book being
different discuss
-
alright so that's a course is very
interesting unique idea in terms of how
-
we understand cultural studies today
-
especially in today's University in
academic climate
-
which i think as you say in your book is
very much focused on sameness and the
-
similarity
-
so pool would you suggest should be
concerned about this
-
this phenomenon the u-turn moment the
Western universalism
-
and the digestion okay the westerner who
was going into the journey
-
needs to know what he have to give up at
some stage
-
in order to really go all the way and
gurus don't want to tell them that
-
because girls want lots o easy code
words is the disciples without giving
-
them a corner store you're saying that
-
you going to yoga at some point in time
the idea that you're gonna and the
-
practice of yoga are going to collide
with
-
for instance the nineteen created
Christianity which talks about original
-
sin and very historical
-
things so you're then assuming that most
Western civilizational
-
accomplishment and thought is predicated
on a question
-
not as urgent judeo-christian and then
the Enlightenment movement starting with
-
Hagel
-
continues a western chauvinism
interested in
-
explosives i do. for like the the
rationalistic
-
trend at the Enlightenment plus they
have the same problem I did
-
crew results in the same kind phenomenon
yes that
-
superior yes other interesting kind of
that kind of approach
-
so if that's the you know can add that
the rest of the Western movement what
-
would you say is approaching it to
-
wanted as the antagonist from the Indian
side and being different
-
well the the Indians have bought into
this western US liza
-
the coup that started translating sounds
good words into english
-
even when that distort for example
they've started replacing at man with
-
Sol
-
even though so there's not reincarnate
and so does not exist in any move their
-
plants and out plan does
-
so even though the didn't mean enough so
it is not the same as up a new kind of
-
distort the meaning about me when you're
basing its or
-
it's popular to do that it's easy to do
that it's going to be easy way out
-
I anything that they do do that in order
to
-
because I don't think that left the
group had been digest have because get
-
digested
-
like that a lot of pride a guess it is
because the girl was compromised the
-
picture brought by people compromise
-
so it it dilutes the tradition into
digestible iti
-
so it takes something which may not be
digesting well which has its own
-
legitimacy which demands being respected
as itself
-
and it brings it down like the enzymes
in the in the stomach
-
to a reduced form so it's easy to digest
and that's good for the
-
but is it was the city he can make a
good business out of that
-
so I think the Indians are into the
gurus I do this and as far as Indian
-
intellectuals are concerned Sonu sized
-
in there in their education I all the
universities in India
-
that teaching western philosophy in the
philosophy department as Western
-
anthropology Martin's being applied
-
now by Indians the West in modern
history and sociology being applied
-
so in the humanities the Western
universities and has sort of become
-
entrenched and I call that meant
organizations so it is a
-
it to the is I would say the resistors
does not exist
-
and I have tried to create that
resistance by writing this book
-
okay I see so then %uh the book is
written and the groundwork is laid
-
for this revolution now how do you
envision that taking place but say that
-
we
-
we see a copy of your book in the hands
a most university students what kind of
-
changes do you anticipate
-
so it's I just came from what month long
tour of India
-
and I had 15 events okay so University
of Delhi has decided to
-
adopt this book for the MA class all
starting to grow as a person
-
so I expect IIT Kanpur IIT Macross
-
really liked it amid the University City
or four academic institutions really
-
like it
-
and I'm invited back to sever more
academic institution including but not
-
in the University IIT Kharagpur
-
in my next trip which is in January 21
segment of people that I'm
-
able to get into already he within one
month is the Academy
-
certain parts of the UK the second group
are burros
-
I had for guru movements invite
-
me and teach their students were not
going to become so I these editorials in
-
that
-
in the next few years and these are not
sort of tribute people they're very
-
big-name people I am I was I was at the
event when should I spend many hours
-
giving a seminar
-
on how they should keep certain things
not translated
-
how you should be worse to gays and
understand the West on your own terms
-
and we have heard such good words poorer
picture which means
-
my view of the other and design or
technique ok debating among different
-
schools within India
-
so we should go put a picture of the
west is what I have told them
-
and we should have comparative religion
comparative philosophy
-
different ideas of his tee talk to our
next generation of
-
spiritual leaders so the fact that these
girls are taking this matter seriously
-
in writing me back to teach more
-
is a good site I think that as India
rises in material terms and in business
-
terms
-
there is also renewed self-confidence to
discover who we really are
-
and throw away the colonial model that
we've been talk so the third group
-
that like this are people in the
corporate world
-
so I was hosted by a few corporate group
in group of industrialists businessmen
-
who want to know there when we are on
the world stage which Indian businesses
-
are
-
when we go on the world stage and we
negotiate with americans with Chinese
-
with Japanese been
-
French russians each of them have a
sense of who they are in terms of the
-
distinctiveness the Russian is
-
not want we mixed as an englishman he's
very clear on what it means to be
-
russian
-
the Chinese vase short about his sense
of what Chinese means
-
its history its ideology Japanese no
matter how progressive and how
-
modernize they are they're still very
Japanese in their culture
-
so what you are we they want to know are
Indians want to know who are we
-
when there are being themselves who are
we
-
and the fact that they had his need that
they have this desire to understand that
-
they think that the question is a valid
question
-
and inviting people like me is very
encouraging so I would say that the
-
the market for these this type of
thinking starts with the academy and the
-
gurus
-
and the the corporate professionals
alrighty really and it sounds like you
-
really tapped into the like us to buy
-
time and and kind of a sea change in the
way that we're looking at these new
-
things
-
but for the majority of us who are you
know in classrooms and schools and just
-
anywhere else where Western universalism
is still very pleasant what kind of
-
advice would you have for how to push
back against it
-
in our own lives and what could seem
like a more minor way
-
so first get my book and read away okay
we do that and you go to www
-
being different book dot com okay want
to learn be interviewing different book
-
the word book as important as being
different book dot com because being
-
definitely taken so
-
being different book dot com and there
you see excerpts you see a lot of videos
-
you can actually spend 10 hours as
watching videos of his discussions
-
debates
-
like last night's discussion with the
Harvard professor
-
will be able to breed up in a few days I
had to
-
a discussion with mark tully famous BBC
correspondent in India
-
and he talked as it Anglican member the
Anglican Church will be opening a very
-
probably
-
and I talked as a Hindu and we had a 1/2
hour conversation on being different
-
so a a lot of information you can get by
watching these videos and
-
the base material posted their and the
book is available you can click and buy
-
the book
-
I think that's a first step because the
book is very I i believe that these are
-
very
-
regional our the box new ideas what's
different about us
-
and it's not political so I'm not asking
people to joy to have
-
anything to do with any political
movement or political organization this
-
is more philosophy
-
so it's a philosophical view of how
we're different and in our lifestyle how
-
we're different
-
rather than political mobilization
-
okay that's very interesting so on now
that's okay since we've gotten some
-
information about the book and about
-
your philosophy and I'm sure our viewers
would like to see a little bit more
-
about your background and I personally
am very curious what kind experiences
-
is there anything in particular that you
had that I inspired you to write
-
being different or to rate I know you're
the other two other books
-
breaking India and then you're also the
inspiration for invading the sacred
-
which is that we're both very
influential works
-
in the same vein to what inspired you to
to go into this field into
-
pick up the subject well I left bank
corporate
-
world and my business life and I was 44
and I decided that is to bring more of
-
the same I should become
-
I should discovered my flight been a
bigger sense
-
and I hadn't been formally trained in
the humanities I wanted learned about
-
myself and my spiritual tradition and
history
-
astoria foundation with my own money
called infinity foundation
-
and first we did this experiment a
funding a whole lot of academic people
-
thinking that we get the right people
and then they do this work
-
but I found that I was more imaginative
than them
-
able to think out of the box and besides
the lack of imagination is also a lack
-
of courage
-
and arrested academics tend to be very
much into one box 1
-
discipline one set of theories and this
kato sort of 10 moving out of it
-
a few visionaries I like that but many
of them already boxed in
-
so I found after 10 years of
experimenting with many kind of economic
-
people many conferences
-
I decided that I should start doing this
myself and so I started reading walking
-
tour a success for
-
started giving talks in PowerPoint
presentation which were very well
-
received
-
and in the last thing for your story
books so I am actually self-taught
-
and have developed these ideas by a lot
of argumentation with people from
-
various ideological point of view
-
were in the Academy and don't since I
don't have to pursue a career in order
-
to please anybody
-
I don't have to spend all our time in
administrative work
-
so I can get up at five in the morning
in reading research and spend
-
12-13 hours a day seven days a week
doing this kind of research
-
which is a beautiful luxury because
people in the Academy would not have
-
that kind of time and freedom to do so
much research
-
so I've been doing this for seventeen
years now and these books are the
-
product of my own discoveries in my own
findings
-
okay and I'm I think I I just wanna know
-
if you succeed wouldn't be there isn't
-
would be have a in in addition to
-
Western universalism islamic an organism
Chinese in North minimum
-
lebanese announcement and we will have
one morning or something not
-
we will have our contribution at the
table
-
as an equal I where we have a a
tradition of looking at things a certain
-
way
-
our radio medicine how radio humans
physiology
-
mind consciousness cost most animal
rights
-
environmentalism teamwork you know
-
human rights all of these things
leadership our martyrs
-
of the way the world is the way humanity
is
-
would be then put on the table data on
par with everybody else
-
and considered as something worth
looking into
-
and looking into critically rejecting
what doesn't work and accepting what
-
does work
-
and the ID I don't think that our
tradition is frozen
-
this is a very important point I don't
think that it's a frozen thing that you
-
can use mine it like in a mine
-
the amount to go wrong to iron ores fix
its not like a tree which is going on
-
growing
-
so it's not organic its fixed so you can
minded and syndicated
-
but a civilization is great our
civilization continues to evolve
-
continues to produce new fruit
-
if you keep nurturing the roads the the
the trees of Indian tradition is
-
producing new protein you harvest all
the time
-
so my idea is to revive the roots of our
civilization
-
so that for the modern era is producing
fruit which are relevant for today
-
today's health crisis today is a you
know how preventive medicine today is
-
a like instead of people on prozac in on
valium in all these men to help things
-
what does our tradition offer by way of
Southern I'm practices
-
to create mental stability and harmony
so
-
we have solutions we're not the only
ones we have solutions
-
and we certainly also have our problems
that we should deal with but
-
all this should be put on the table on
par for every civilization nothing
-
specific for us it should be the islamic
people in the
-
Native American people the chinese the
westernization or be
-
in ball in a kind of a cross
fertilization and I double civilization
-
so that's what I would like to see
-
Thursday interesting that you should ask
that question doctor saying because
-
I know a lot of scholars have said that
this dialogue across cultural
-
civilizational paradigm should be
advanced
-
but India an index level is Asian has
historically been one of the most recent
-
to join this
-
and one which is still there
underrepresented in the dialogue of
-
civilizations as I'm sure you would
agree
-
do you have any insight as to why yes be
the case yes
-
because when I started this project
15-17 years ago
-
India was represented or misrepresented
by those Indians were the
-
hi heavily colonized the postcode miss
connors they're very far left by the
-
people
-
who hated the classical Indian
civilization who who considered is to be
-
really didn't buy the entire mother
might not to be trusted as religion it's
-
one other
-
not trusted with so all of Marx's
critique of religion
-
just simply applied the Dharma
traditions and so they had which is a
-
quest detrimental because most indian
civilizations
-
rooted in these time a condition
corrected correct so they're they're the
-
colonial
-
hatred for the civilization also got
into these guys
-
and why they were both colonias in the
sense they were here they were
-
criticizing colonialism for its material
in physical
-
interference and devastation but in
terms of philosophical ideas they were
-
not
-
learn it in size bed or the Sanskrit
texts did not understand the
-
the how much additions Jenny they were
eliminated from that they were very and
-
use a scanner people
-
so there were all over the United States
and Europe
-
in various departments of South Asian
Studies speaking for us representing us
-
some love most in Austin they're very
prominent people
-
there's some people in Harvard for
example who are Indian origin and every
-
prominent people
-
so these people to get the ambassador's
of Indian civilization
-
and therefore the problem got worse and
in in this ten people who think that the
-
problem that India has is that there is
too much baggage award civilization
-
which we should get rid of
-
and while I agree that there are
problems actually you think trying to
-
jettison that identity which yes us
different yes and they are very sick and
-
in
-
if I talk in favor of Indian
civilization that think I was going on
-
to some
-
political party that is that something
good for political party
-
and they accuse you and the brain you
but there is a decoupling of politics
-
you can leave the politics behind
-
and you can talk about %uh civilizations
knowledge system
-
so I when I talk about the time I i'm
not talking about it as a political
-
movement today
-
but I'm talking about it as a classical
knowledge system like this great thought
-
nobody thinks that your pup member of a
political party if you think of kato
-
are some pretty some we are a stalker
now would be a political party we might
-
all consider signing up right
-
so I i feel that there's a dharmic
civilizational
-
worldview which ought to be studied as a
knowledge system
-
not get into any politics okay see you
want to distance that
-
that yes from politics that sounds like
you believe that politics was actually
-
part of what led to this problem
-
politics that made it worse because
politics is tainted and brought a lot of
-
branding
-
so it's become very difficult for a guy
like me
-
to talk about being the qualities of my
civilization
-
without somebody being very suspicious
that maybe he speaks for BJP and maybe
-
unofficially behind directly may be
helping them so this is a very
-
irritating to constantly say well you
know you've got to understand
-
if not its system of a certain country
like and any the ask me why do you want
-
to call it Indian
-
Indian civilization if they if these are
you there were some things why
-
I said because there is a Greek
civilization there is a Chinese
-
civilization
-
and the place where it originated is not
the place where it's it
-
effects are limited its effects are all
over the world
-
and they should be all over the world
but you give good name
-
based on where the civilization
originated there is definitely a French
-
culture they teach it in your
universities is it
-
is Italian cuisine why do what Italian
cuisine why did you just call it
-
spaghetti
-
so the point is that things are named
after the their origin
-
and and why and I did worse it back to
the gentleman's and yayy D having very
-
complex about
-
Indian civilization in a positive sense
and the back window into that
-
okay so it it sounds then you feel that
we need a renaissance at Indian scholars
-
who does not
-
were not feeling the need to distance
themselves from the the roots and
-
psychological historical with this
tradition so
-
here were coming to kind of an
interesting interesting
-
conundrum in index studies which I know
that we've spoken about a lot at the
-
Center for index study is then that is
-
how does this indicate Voice get created
especially considering the huge
-
diversity
-
within the in the traditions and the
lack of say
-
you know i'd a chain a profession my god
nice said to the Lord
-
things like that and not just the third
you are not a monolithic yet so I
-
obviously I agree I adjourned that issue
very white people my
-
Mon morn made who is the Indian waz
-
what is the Indian point if you're right
and with greater
-
this and when there's a guy identity
yeah and when there's so many views so I
-
the way I answered it
-
is not that don't know Murray the normal
way is you get all the Indian schools
-
together in time to build some harmony
and that hasn't worked
-
I never tried that okay to criticize me
for why did you go and
-
have accountable under my eyes I said
because it didn't work for
-
does the viewers I work Friday you could
be straight and my method is a very
-
different
-
my method is that if I want sought to
figure out what's common among the time
-
I traditions
-
I will ignore that question I will and
said ask how are we different from
-
others
-
and maybe the way that different from
others is common amongst us
-
OKC would establish commonalities by
distinct my sisters
-
that is called the poor affectionate at
which means that study the other
-
so by studying the other I found that
the core DNA of christianity is the
-
nineteen creed
-
and I found that the nice thing create
is incompatible with carmine
-
reincarnation
-
okay so then I found that all the Indian
traditions
-
share kar my reincarnation so where we
are common is how we're different from
-
him in there we have a tentative
-
the in deploys establish so that's one
point like that I've discovered
-
four different major areas of
commonality within the new conditions
-
and difference with respect to the west
ok and are they worried it could you
-
briefly detail
-
when one is the air the Western is a
history cedric
-
in other words the the prophetic history
is very important
-
and the all the Indian traditions you
can and
-
raise your level of consciousness
through various traditions various
-
techniques which
-
people may disagree with them but they
all claim that some techniques
-
and the other a historical so the the
recovery of the highest
-
level of consciousness available to each
and every person what we've got such a
-
turn on
-
that is very different from the History
Center's out with so this is an
-
experiential or a phenomenological
-
what I cause a embodied no in body Mr
deny such as
-
as opposed to most opposed to historic
just resent resistors second one is
-
integral unity we're synthetic unity so
the
-
the unifying things in the Indian
tradition very very strong
-
and that's why it has to be contrasted
with say the the synthetic nature of
-
reality the synthetic nature of
-
of knowledge dysentery nature of the
individual in the western part
-
so even westerners the the model the
body is a synthetic community of parts
-
whereas the holistic ideas very
different this integral unity
-
okay and where the why the Indian
approach to Don's
-
is integrity unified with philosophy and
music is
-
integrity unified philosophy western
dance Western philosophy but not into
-
each other
-
science kit contains the unity of all
philosophy did
-
call the philosophy and all the of
Performing Arts alternate
-
so you'll find that the equivalent of
Humanities in the Indian system
-
are integrally unified and not just into
into disagree and
-
put together in that way that's the
second one the third one is
-
the added you to what chaos a how
Indians had a chaos
-
or what the westerners call chaos is
very different then what Westerners
-
have however had gas and that's the
party by the most exciting chapters in
-
this book in this chapter for
-
comfort with chaos comfort with
uncertainty and be greedy doubt
-
I was interviewed by ABC news for the
sunday program at the couple made up
-
and the guy asked me the question how do
I go and explain to the Americans
-
all this chaos so I said well you know
the chaos in your mind
-
because it its cognitive overload that
you are facing
-
there is so much complexity be on your
models you want cannot put on this
-
complex in
-
so because a martyr crashes you calling
it chaos
-
but if you go around asking the various
individuals you know they are all doing
-
that thing they don't think that any
chaos to give
-
be happy doing going about doing what
they're doing you watching them a bit
-
binding chaos
-
you found it so interesting that what
was supposed to be a five-minute
-
interview went on for three hours
-
you're not a part of their documentary
was on my discussion
-
because I the worst big is and put the
there cause of this chaos
-
feeling not on the object that they're
looking at but on the subject that was
-
doing this looking
-
and I find this a come forward with a
multiplicity
-
many threads going on multi tasking it
an Indian
-
getting get meeting is talking to be
she's talking to D
-
is placed into a and talking to have and
the West misleading they're very
-
confused by what was going on why what
is happening
-
so in my business what I found that when
I would have these kinda meetings
-
and the meetings over West never come to
the union that are printed out
-
printed out but the they can do many
things and figure out what's relevant to
-
make it cut paste pic pic figured out
-
and the West they would come to me and
ask you know what happened I'm confused
-
what was going on when the site but this
guy said this man this guy's at that
-
so there is a certain discomfort
-
with what they would consider chaos they
want things to be linear
-
we want things to be super protest third
one and the fourth one is the non
-
prostate ability of such good words
-
opening that where certain there's a
reason for it because month right
-
vibration and you cannot translated
-
you can I replace but months or with
another because eat my vision has a
-
distinct effect like each chemist
-
chemistry Kate chemical would have a
different effect I don't trust
-
the sound and the substance at the
Montreux yes just as important as the
-
meeting as a meanie
-
and so I've given examples of 20 or 25
nonprofit it was in this book in Chapter
-
five
-
I and i intend to take that Army Corps
body mind that
-
so these are some building blocks in
solid pillars of what is
-
different and non digestible into the
west the only way to assimilate
-
this is to distorted and make a
digestible
-
and I'm trying to resist the digestion
by keeping that authentic stuff
-
okay love I think that that it sounds
like you're off to a wonderful start
-
and I hope that as much as weekend in
our viewers can we can help you in that
-
mission to prevented a disability
-
and of course you said we can buy the
book being different book
-
dot com yes I would love to have more
people buy
-
and in that you can also join the
discussion we have two thousand people
-
already involved in discussing this book
online
-
so people can join the discussion and he
made to me and I'd be delighted to
-
respond to your questions
-
okay well thank you so much for taking
the time to to thank you for having me a
-
drink is always to doctor saying
-
or posting as it's been a pleasure
discussing this book with you
-
thank you so much thank you think is I
do you think is the re
-
and this was another and is enough
-
but that ending waz soon we will be back
again
-
with that and and this month assess and
about to
-
in the boys thank you very much