WEBVTT

00:00:01.331 --> 00:00:02.683
Fresh out of college,

00:00:02.683 --> 00:00:04.900
I went to work for a consulting firm.

00:00:05.259 --> 00:00:08.963
During orientation the leaders
dished out advice.

00:00:09.287 --> 00:00:12.870
Amongst them was one pithy
council I will never forget.

00:00:13.369 --> 00:00:16.510
He told us, "Be easy to manage."

00:00:16.814 --> 00:00:20.626
Considering how naïve
I really was at the time,

00:00:20.626 --> 00:00:22.416
I took his advice to heart,

00:00:22.416 --> 00:00:23.934
I told myself,

00:00:23.934 --> 00:00:26.938
"Yes, I will be the ultimate team player,

00:00:26.938 --> 00:00:28.904
I will do everything I'm told.

00:00:28.904 --> 00:00:30.884
I will be easy to manage."

00:00:31.658 --> 00:00:34.173
It wasn't until I arrived
in graduate school

00:00:34.173 --> 00:00:39.112
and witnessed firsthand the criminal
actions of scientists and engineers

00:00:39.112 --> 00:00:41.935
in the water crisis in Flint, Michigan

00:00:41.935 --> 00:00:46.309
that I realized how dangerous
and yet surprisingly common

00:00:46.309 --> 00:00:48.584
this line of thinking really is.

00:00:48.932 --> 00:00:50.110
Make no mistake,

00:00:50.110 --> 00:00:51.543
the Flint water crisis

00:00:51.543 --> 00:00:55.421
is one of the most egregious
environmental injustices of our time.

00:00:55.688 --> 00:00:57.519
For over 18 months,

00:00:57.519 --> 00:00:59.196
100,000 residents,

00:00:59.196 --> 00:01:01.595
including thousands of young children,

00:01:01.595 --> 00:01:05.478
were exposed to contaminated
drinking water with high levels of lead.

00:01:06.223 --> 00:01:08.122
Lead is a potent neurotoxin

00:01:08.122 --> 00:01:11.885
which causes cognitive
and developmental disabilities

00:01:11.885 --> 00:01:16.097
and is especially harmful to growing
fetuses and young children.

00:01:16.600 --> 00:01:20.365
We've known about its dangers
since the Roman Empire.

00:01:20.958 --> 00:01:23.448
Amongst a whole host of health issues,

00:01:23.448 --> 00:01:27.165
12 people died by contracting
Legionnaires' disease.

00:01:27.636 --> 00:01:29.461
Flint's water infrastructure --

00:01:29.461 --> 00:01:32.565
the complex network
of underground pipes --

00:01:32.565 --> 00:01:34.633
has been severely damaged.

00:01:35.252 --> 00:01:38.435
And while the water quality
is slowly improving

00:01:38.435 --> 00:01:40.509
and the pipes are being replaced now,

00:01:40.509 --> 00:01:42.318
more than two years later,

00:01:42.318 --> 00:01:45.155
the water is still not safe to drink.

00:01:46.340 --> 00:01:49.248
So, people are still in shock.

00:01:49.248 --> 00:01:50.740
They ask themselves,

00:01:50.740 --> 00:01:52.868
"How could this have happened?"

00:01:53.456 --> 00:01:58.008
The short answer is the crisis began
when an emergency manager,

00:01:58.008 --> 00:02:00.605
appointed by Michigan's governor,

00:02:00.605 --> 00:02:05.063
decided to switch their water source
to a local river to save money.

00:02:05.327 --> 00:02:07.546
But it continued for so long

00:02:07.546 --> 00:02:11.279
because scientists and engineers
at government agencies

00:02:11.279 --> 00:02:12.477
in the state of Michigan,

00:02:12.477 --> 00:02:14.356
and in the federal government,

00:02:14.356 --> 00:02:17.793
did not follow federal regulations
for treating the water right.

00:02:18.985 --> 00:02:20.206
What was more,

00:02:20.206 --> 00:02:23.521
they actively cheated on the law
and orchestrated coverups.

00:02:24.228 --> 00:02:27.284
They ridiculed residents asking for help

00:02:27.284 --> 00:02:29.189
while publicly insisting that the brown
smelly water coming out of the tap

00:02:29.189 --> 00:02:33.391
that the brown smelly water
coming out of the tap was safe to drink.

00:02:33.843 --> 00:02:38.129
The system at the local, state
and federal levels

00:02:38.129 --> 00:02:41.614
completely failed to protect
our most vulnerable,

00:02:41.614 --> 00:02:45.612
and an entire population
was left to fend for itself.

00:02:46.240 --> 00:02:48.820
Now, amidst this justice,

00:02:48.820 --> 00:02:51.171
Flint residents were rallying together.

00:02:51.171 --> 00:02:54.467
Amongst them were some
amazing women of Flint,

00:02:54.467 --> 00:02:56.419
mothers concerned about their kids,

00:02:56.419 --> 00:03:00.335
who came together forming
many grassroots coalitions,

00:03:00.335 --> 00:03:04.160
and these groups started protesting
and demanding change.

00:03:04.591 --> 00:03:08.508
The group also reached out
to outside scientists for help,

00:03:08.508 --> 00:03:10.044
and a few responded.

00:03:10.519 --> 00:03:14.197
Amongst them was a guy
named Miguel Del Toral,

00:03:14.197 --> 00:03:16.794
a water expert at the US EPA --

00:03:16.794 --> 00:03:18.794
the Environmental Protection Agency --

00:03:18.794 --> 00:03:21.536
who actually wrote the scientific memo,

00:03:21.536 --> 00:03:24.569
and sent it to the state of Michigan
and the federal government

00:03:24.569 --> 00:03:26.933
to bring their attention to this problem.

00:03:27.345 --> 00:03:30.104
He was characterized a "rogue employee,"

00:03:30.104 --> 00:03:31.568
and silenced.

00:03:32.819 --> 00:03:35.710
In collaboration with Flint residents,

00:03:35.710 --> 00:03:39.673
our research team here at Tech
of students and scientists

00:03:39.673 --> 00:03:41.445
led by professor Marc Edwards,

00:03:41.445 --> 00:03:43.606
conducted citywide testing

00:03:43.606 --> 00:03:46.637
to prove that Flint's water
was indeed contaminated,

00:03:46.637 --> 00:03:48.698
even toxic in some homes.

00:03:49.654 --> 00:03:52.816
We substantiated what Flint
had been screaming for months,

00:03:52.816 --> 00:03:55.549
and put it on the Internet
for the world to see.

00:03:56.021 --> 00:03:59.022
Now, when I was getting involved,

00:03:59.022 --> 00:04:00.439
when I said yes to this,

00:04:00.439 --> 00:04:03.703
I had no idea what I was getting into,

00:04:03.703 --> 00:04:06.943
but every second of this journey
has been totally worth it.

00:04:07.242 --> 00:04:09.944
This was science
and service to the public.

00:04:10.113 --> 00:04:12.665
This is what I came
to graduate school for,

00:04:12.665 --> 00:04:15.438
and this is how I would
rather spend my life.

00:04:15.992 --> 00:04:18.029
And so this coalition --

00:04:18.029 --> 00:04:23.008
this unlikely coalition of citizens,
pastors, journalists and scientists

00:04:23.008 --> 00:04:27.530
came together to uncover the truth
using science, advocacy and activism.

00:04:27.868 --> 00:04:30.024
A local pediatrician figured out

00:04:30.024 --> 00:04:34.624
that the instances of childhood
lead poisoning had indeed doubled

00:04:34.624 --> 00:04:36.747
in Flint during the crisis.

00:04:37.371 --> 00:04:41.015
And the state of Michigan was forced
to acknowledge the problem

00:04:41.015 --> 00:04:43.345
and take steps to correct it.

00:04:43.550 --> 00:04:44.553
This group,

00:04:44.553 --> 00:04:45.552
and many others,

00:04:45.552 --> 00:04:47.767
got Flint's kids protected.

00:04:48.006 --> 00:04:49.264
A few months later,

00:04:49.264 --> 00:04:52.917
President Obama came in
and declared a federal emergency,

00:04:52.917 --> 00:04:56.448
and now Flint is getting more
than 600 million dollars

00:04:56.448 --> 00:04:59.790
in healthcare, nutrition, education

00:04:59.790 --> 00:05:02.493
and overhauling their
water infrastructure.

00:05:03.233 --> 00:05:06.410
However, the arrogance

00:05:06.410 --> 00:05:09.230
and the callous disregard
for public health

00:05:09.230 --> 00:05:13.589
shown by scientists and engineers
at these government agencies

00:05:13.589 --> 00:05:15.253
is beyond belief.

00:05:15.997 --> 00:05:19.562
These unhealthy cultures
that are festering in these groups,

00:05:19.562 --> 00:05:23.530
where the focus is on meeting
regulations and checking boxes

00:05:23.530 --> 00:05:27.464
as opposed to protecting
public health is just appalling.

00:05:27.858 --> 00:05:32.182
Just consider this email
that an EPA employee wrote

00:05:32.182 --> 00:05:34.329
where she goes,

00:05:34.329 --> 00:05:38.816
"I'm not so sure Flint is a community
we want to go out on a limb for."

00:05:40.077 --> 00:05:44.632
The dehumanization of an entire
population could not be more obvious.

00:05:45.090 --> 00:05:50.022
Now, contrast that to the first
canon of engineering,

00:05:50.022 --> 00:05:53.331
which in my opinion should be
the first law of humanity.

00:05:53.527 --> 00:05:57.425
"To hold paramount the health,
safety and welfare of the public,"

00:05:57.425 --> 00:05:58.881
above all else.

00:05:59.158 --> 00:06:03.830
This is the Hippocratic Oath we've
rarely acknowledged, let alone embraced.

00:06:04.692 --> 00:06:06.883
And so when scientists and engineers,

00:06:06.883 --> 00:06:08.979
very much like medical doctors,

00:06:08.979 --> 00:06:10.432
screw up,

00:06:10.432 --> 00:06:12.038
people can get hurt --

00:06:12.038 --> 00:06:13.175
even die.

00:06:13.563 --> 00:06:18.131
If our professionals and even
students fail to get that,

00:06:18.131 --> 00:06:20.185
society pays a huge price.

00:06:21.652 --> 00:06:25.946
Buried deep in history lies
a character I deeply admire --

00:06:25.946 --> 00:06:28.804
an engineer named Peter Palchinsky.

00:06:29.558 --> 00:06:32.396
He lived in the time of the Soviet Union.

00:06:32.558 --> 00:06:37.573
And Palchinsky repeatedly got in trouble
for his radical honesty

00:06:37.573 --> 00:06:43.151
and willingness to point out major
flaws in the Soviet's mindless pursuit

00:06:43.151 --> 00:06:45.504
of rapid industrialization.

00:06:45.887 --> 00:06:49.746
Everyone was expected to follow orders
coming from the top.

00:06:49.899 --> 00:06:54.238
Anyone asking questions or offering
feedback was unwelcome.

00:06:54.553 --> 00:06:59.854
The Soviets had created the largest
army of engineers the world had ever seen,

00:06:59.854 --> 00:07:04.817
and yet most of them were mere cogs
in a gigantic machine heading for doom.

00:07:05.614 --> 00:07:07.169
Palchinsky on the other hand,

00:07:07.169 --> 00:07:11.276
implored engineers to look
at the economic, political

00:07:11.276 --> 00:07:14.021
and social consequences of their actions.

00:07:14.021 --> 00:07:15.273
In other words,

00:07:15.273 --> 00:07:17.051
be more public-focused.

00:07:17.051 --> 00:07:20.967
His fearless voice of reason
was seen as a threat

00:07:20.967 --> 00:07:22.873
to the political establishment,

00:07:22.873 --> 00:07:26.643
and Joseph Stalin
had him executed in 1929.

00:07:28.001 --> 00:07:32.021
Palchinsky's view on technocrats
is very different

00:07:32.021 --> 00:07:34.492
from one that is still very popular,

00:07:34.492 --> 00:07:36.667
still very common.

00:07:37.320 --> 00:07:43.209
That of a dispassionate researcher
working in his ivory tower lab,

00:07:43.209 --> 00:07:46.377
or a nerdy engineer
working in his cubicle.

00:07:46.662 --> 00:07:49.079
Brilliant, no doubt,

00:07:49.079 --> 00:07:51.032
yet somehow cut off from the world,

00:07:51.032 --> 00:07:53.267
shows little emotion --

00:07:53.267 --> 00:07:55.875
kind of like Spock from "Star Trek,"

00:07:55.875 --> 00:07:57.125
you know?

00:07:57.125 --> 00:07:58.384
This guy?

00:07:58.384 --> 00:07:59.427
(Laughter)

00:07:59.991 --> 00:08:01.762
Let's [try] the Spock salute.

00:08:02.345 --> 00:08:05.054
I don't think I'll succeed ...

00:08:05.054 --> 00:08:06.899
see I [can] be Spock.

00:08:06.899 --> 00:08:09.060
Thank goodness, I [can] be Spock.

00:08:09.060 --> 00:08:10.078
(Laughter)

00:08:11.856 --> 00:08:16.351
I was reminded of this distinction
because a recent article came out

00:08:16.351 --> 00:08:19.600
in a very reputable scientific journal,

00:08:19.600 --> 00:08:22.412
which kind of characterized our Flint work

00:08:22.412 --> 00:08:24.945
as driven by "youthful idealism,"

00:08:24.945 --> 00:08:27.393
and "Hollywood's dramatic sensibilities."

00:08:27.707 --> 00:08:32.946
It asks scientists to protect their
research funding and institutions

00:08:32.946 --> 00:08:34.380
at all costs,

00:08:34.380 --> 00:08:36.560
no matter how just the cause.

00:08:36.560 --> 00:08:39.866
And if you think you have to
get involved with something,

00:08:39.866 --> 00:08:41.924
even if it's an emergency,

00:08:41.924 --> 00:08:46.044
try finding an activist group or an NGO,

00:08:46.044 --> 00:08:49.063
and obtain the full support
of the academic community --

00:08:49.063 --> 00:08:50.579
whatever that means --

00:08:50.579 --> 00:08:52.563
before you get involved.

00:08:52.897 --> 00:08:56.922
Not one mention of our moral
and professional obligation

00:08:56.922 --> 00:08:59.142
of preventing harm to the public,

00:08:59.142 --> 00:09:02.534
or the fact that with all this expertise,

00:09:02.534 --> 00:09:05.582
resources and for some even tenure,

00:09:05.582 --> 00:09:08.115
to, you know, accomplish this task.

00:09:08.953 --> 00:09:11.806
I'm not saying every
scientist should be an activist.

00:09:11.806 --> 00:09:16.546
There are real and sometimes very painful
consequences of speaking up,

00:09:16.546 --> 00:09:19.268
but to denounce this idea,

00:09:19.268 --> 00:09:21.558
this possiblity so completely

00:09:21.558 --> 00:09:23.977
so that you can protect research funding,

00:09:23.977 --> 00:09:26.625
simply screams of self-serving cowardice,

00:09:26.625 --> 00:09:31.826
and [these are] not the ideals that we
would want to pass to our students.

00:09:32.848 --> 00:09:36.233
And so you may think
all this sounds great,

00:09:36.233 --> 00:09:39.833
but you'll never completely change
organizational cultures,

00:09:39.833 --> 00:09:43.903
or imbibe mindsets in students
and professionals

00:09:43.903 --> 00:09:46.563
to look at their work as a public good --

00:09:46.563 --> 00:09:48.623
science in service to the public.

00:09:49.210 --> 00:09:50.808
Maybe so,

00:09:50.808 --> 00:09:53.073
but could a big reason for that be

00:09:53.073 --> 00:09:55.733
that we are not training
our students right?

00:09:56.149 --> 00:09:58.614
Because if you look closely,

00:09:58.614 --> 00:10:03.435
our education system today
is focused more on creating

00:10:03.435 --> 00:10:08.585
what ex-Yale professor
Bill Deresiewiczs calls "excellent sheep;"

00:10:08.585 --> 00:10:11.525
young people who are smart and ambitious,

00:10:11.525 --> 00:10:16.315
and yet somehow risk-averse,
timid, directionless,

00:10:16.315 --> 00:10:18.945
and sometimes, full of themselves.

00:10:19.147 --> 00:10:20.907
Now, kids --

00:10:20.907 --> 00:10:23.817
we fell in love with science
when we were kids,

00:10:23.817 --> 00:10:27.977
and yet we somehow spend most of our time
during high school and college

00:10:27.977 --> 00:10:29.497
just jumping through hoops,

00:10:29.497 --> 00:10:32.987
and doing things so that we
can polish our resume

00:10:32.987 --> 00:10:34.837
instead of sitting down,

00:10:34.837 --> 00:10:37.367
and reflecting on what we want to do

00:10:37.367 --> 00:10:39.417
and who we want to be.

00:10:41.323 --> 00:10:43.839
And so ...

00:10:43.839 --> 00:10:47.529
the markers of empathy
in our college graduates

00:10:47.529 --> 00:10:50.695
have been dropping dramatically
in the past two decades,

00:10:50.695 --> 00:10:53.444
while those of narcissism are on the rise.

00:10:53.444 --> 00:10:56.059
There is also a growing culture
of disengagement

00:10:56.059 --> 00:10:59.497
between engineering students
and the public.

00:10:59.866 --> 00:11:04.999
We are trained to build bridges
and solve complex problems,

00:11:04.999 --> 00:11:09.870
but not how to think or live
or be a citizen of this world.

00:11:10.201 --> 00:11:14.617
My undergraduate years
were explicit job preparation,

00:11:14.617 --> 00:11:18.823
and I cannot tell you how suffocating
and painful it was at times.

00:11:21.712 --> 00:11:24.245
Some people think the solution
to great engineers,

00:11:24.245 --> 00:11:25.292
to great scientists,

00:11:25.292 --> 00:11:26.911
is more technical training.

00:11:27.081 --> 00:11:28.337
Maybe so.

00:11:28.337 --> 00:11:31.895
But where are the discussions
on ethical decision making,

00:11:31.895 --> 00:11:33.905
or building character,

00:11:33.905 --> 00:11:37.124
or discerning right from wrong?

00:11:37.717 --> 00:11:41.733
Consider this project
that I deeply love and admire.

00:11:42.415 --> 00:11:45.021
It's called The Heroic
Imagination Project,

00:11:45.021 --> 00:11:47.510
a brainchild of Dr.Phil Zimbardo,

00:11:47.510 --> 00:11:50.287
famous for The Stanford Prison Experiment.

00:11:50.455 --> 00:11:55.723
This program seeks to train
school-going children around the world

00:11:55.723 --> 00:11:59.186
to look at themselves
as heroes-in-waiting,

00:11:59.186 --> 00:12:01.101
or heroes-in-training.

00:12:01.232 --> 00:12:06.606
So, these young minds work over time
to develop skills and virtues

00:12:06.606 --> 00:12:08.924
so that when the opportunity comes,

00:12:08.924 --> 00:12:11.422
no matter what that opportunity [is,]

00:12:11.422 --> 00:12:14.030
to stand up and do the right thing.

00:12:14.519 --> 00:12:15.972
In other words,

00:12:15.972 --> 00:12:17.889
anyone can be a hero.

00:12:18.495 --> 00:12:21.314
Think about that idea for a second.

00:12:21.314 --> 00:12:24.725
Why don't we teach science
and engineering like that --

00:12:24.725 --> 00:12:28.840
where heroism and public service
are seen as key values?

00:12:28.840 --> 00:12:31.593
Because indeed it's often heroism

00:12:31.593 --> 00:12:35.364
that is not only the antidote
to public indifference,

00:12:35.364 --> 00:12:39.321
but also to systemic evil
like we saw in Flint.

00:12:40.272 --> 00:12:41.729
And so dream with me

00:12:41.729 --> 00:12:45.451
what a 21st-century scientist
slash engineer could look like.

00:12:45.912 --> 00:12:49.488
Individuals who are driven
to master the sciences

00:12:49.488 --> 00:12:51.634
so that they can serve society,

00:12:51.634 --> 00:12:55.996
and are also aware of the tremendous power
their knowledge and decisions have.

00:12:56.644 --> 00:13:00.561
Folks who are developing
their moral courage at all times,

00:13:00.561 --> 00:13:04.316
and who realize that conflict
and controversy

00:13:04.316 --> 00:13:06.531
are not necessarily bad things

00:13:06.531 --> 00:13:10.401
if our ultimate loyalty
is to the public and the planet.

00:13:11.457 --> 00:13:16.197
These are the people who will
stand up like we did in Flint --

00:13:16.197 --> 00:13:20.193
not to be saviors or heroes in the media,

00:13:20.193 --> 00:13:22.358
but altruistic

00:13:22.358 --> 00:13:27.098
and fundamentally good actors
that you and I can trust.

00:13:27.868 --> 00:13:32.792
Imagine fostering such
a public-focused mindset

00:13:32.792 --> 00:13:37.245
in classes, on service trips and through
activities during college,

00:13:37.245 --> 00:13:38.711
or even high school,

00:13:38.711 --> 00:13:42.548
so that these young minds
will hold onto those ideals

00:13:42.548 --> 00:13:45.043
when they actually enter the real world,

00:13:45.043 --> 00:13:49.189
whether that be consulting,
academia, policy making,

00:13:49.189 --> 00:13:51.981
or even becoming
the president of a country.

00:13:53.686 --> 00:13:57.505
Some of mankind's greatest
challenges lie ahead of us;

00:13:57.509 --> 00:14:00.516
contaminated drinking water
is just one example.

00:14:00.742 --> 00:14:03.043
We could definitely use more --

00:14:03.043 --> 00:14:08.053
nay, we desperately need more
compassionate upstanders

00:14:08.053 --> 00:14:11.005
and public-focused scientists
and engineers

00:14:11.005 --> 00:14:13.104
who will strive to the do right thing,

00:14:13.104 --> 00:14:14.931
and not be easy to manage.

00:14:14.931 --> 00:14:16.101
Thank you.

00:14:16.218 --> 00:14:18.336
(Applause)