0:00:15.012,0:00:17.409
(Circus music)

0:00:21.725,0:00:24.526
[Ted N' Ed's Carnival]

0:00:24.550,0:00:28.475
[John Lloyd's Inventory of the Invisible]

0:00:39.124,0:00:41.578
[Adapted from a TEDTalk[br]given by John Lloyd in 2009]

0:00:41.602,0:00:44.242
June Cohen: Our next speaker[br]has spent his whole career

0:00:44.266,0:00:45.766
eliciting that sense of wonder.

0:00:45.790,0:00:47.142
Please welcome John Lloyd.

0:00:47.166,0:00:48.242
(Applause)

0:00:48.266,0:00:49.422
[Hall of Mirrors]

0:00:50.871,0:00:53.201
The question is, "What is invisible?"

0:00:53.225,0:00:55.654
There's more of it[br]than you think, actually.

0:00:55.678,0:00:58.389
Everything, I would say --[br]everything that matters --

0:00:58.413,0:01:02.620
Except every thing, and except matter.

0:01:02.644,0:01:04.066
We can see matter

0:01:04.090,0:01:06.718
but we can't see what's the matter.

0:01:06.742,0:01:11.850
We can see the stars and the planets[br]but we can't see what holds them apart,

0:01:11.874,0:01:13.248
or what draws them together.

0:01:14.191,0:01:17.001
With matter as with people,[br]we see only the skin of things,

0:01:17.025,0:01:20.806
we can't see into the engine room,[br]we can't see what makes people tick,

0:01:20.830,0:01:22.354
at least not without difficulty,

0:01:22.378,0:01:25.998
and the closer we look at anything,[br]the more it disappears.

0:01:26.022,0:01:28.223
In fact, if you look[br]really closely at stuff,

0:01:28.247,0:01:30.590
if you look at the basic[br]substructure of matter,

0:01:30.614,0:01:32.026
there isn't anything there.

0:01:32.050,0:01:35.196
Electrons disappear in a kind of fuzz,[br]and there is only energy.

0:01:35.220,0:01:37.724
One of the interesting things[br]about invisibility is,

0:01:37.748,0:01:40.670
the things that we can's see,[br]we also can't understand.

0:01:40.694,0:01:44.844
Gravity is one thing that we can't see,[br]and which we don't understand.

0:01:44.868,0:01:47.773
It's the least understood[br]of all the four fundamental forces,

0:01:47.797,0:01:51.340
and the weakest, and nobody really[br]knows what it is or why it's there.

0:01:51.364,0:01:55.031
For what it's worth, Sir Isaac Newton,[br]the greatest scientist who ever lived,

0:01:55.055,0:01:57.493
he thought Jesus came[br]to Earth specifically

0:01:57.517,0:01:59.375
to operate the levers of gravity.

0:01:59.399,0:02:01.304
That's what he thought he was there for.

0:02:01.328,0:02:04.051
So, bright guy, could be wrong[br]on that one, I don't know.

0:02:04.075,0:02:05.089
(Laughter)

0:02:05.113,0:02:09.758
Consciousness. I see all your faces;[br]I've no idea what any of you are thinking.

0:02:09.782,0:02:10.850
Isn't that amazing?

0:02:10.874,0:02:13.636
Isn't it incredible that we can't read[br]each other's minds,

0:02:13.660,0:02:16.052
when we can touch each other,[br]taste each other,

0:02:16.076,0:02:19.410
perhaps, if we get close enough,[br]but we can't read each other's minds.

0:02:19.434,0:02:20.944
I find that quite astonishing.

0:02:20.968,0:02:23.908
In the Sufi faith,[br]this great Middle Eastern religion

0:02:23.932,0:02:26.241
which some claim[br]is the root of all religions,

0:02:26.265,0:02:31.021
Sufi masters are[br]all telepaths, so they say,

0:02:31.045,0:02:33.548
but their main exercise of telepathy

0:02:33.572,0:02:37.674
is to send out powerful signals[br]to the rest of us that it doesn't exist.

0:02:37.698,0:02:41.032
So that's why we don't think it exists;[br]the Sufi masters working on us.

0:02:41.818,0:02:45.217
In the question of consciousness[br]and artificial intelligence,

0:02:45.241,0:02:48.462
artificial intelligence has really,[br]like the study of consciousness,

0:02:48.486,0:02:51.115
gotten nowhere, we have no idea[br]how consciousness works.

0:02:51.139,0:02:53.764
Not only have they not created[br]artificial intelligence,

0:02:53.788,0:02:56.193
they haven't yet created[br]artificial stupidity.

0:02:56.217,0:02:57.969
(Laughter)

0:02:57.993,0:03:02.085
The laws of physics: invisible,[br]eternal, omnipresent, all powerful.

0:03:02.109,0:03:03.251
Remind you of anyone?

0:03:04.052,0:03:05.396
Interesting.

0:03:05.420,0:03:08.586
I'm, as you can guess,[br]not a materialist, I'm an immaterialist.

0:03:08.610,0:03:11.358
And I've found a very useful[br]new word -- ignostic.

0:03:11.382,0:03:12.640
Okay? I'm an ignostic.

0:03:12.664,0:03:13.721
[God?]

0:03:13.745,0:03:16.460
I refuse to be drawn on the question[br]on whether God exists

0:03:16.484,0:03:18.608
until somebody properly defines the terms.

0:03:18.632,0:03:21.257
Another thing we can't see[br]is the human genome.

0:03:21.281,0:03:26.275
And this is increasingly peculiar,[br]because about 20 years ago

0:03:26.299,0:03:30.157
when they started delving into the genome,[br]they thought it would probably contain

0:03:30.181,0:03:31.489
around 100 thousand genes.

0:03:31.513,0:03:34.874
Every year since,[br]it's been revised downwards.

0:03:34.898,0:03:38.291
We now think there are likely[br]to be just over 20 thousand genes

0:03:38.315,0:03:39.531
in the human genome.

0:03:39.555,0:03:42.809
This is extraordinary,[br]because rice -- get this --

0:03:42.833,0:03:45.775
rice is known to have 38 thousand genes.

0:03:45.799,0:03:50.800
Potatoes have 48 chromosomes,[br]two more than people,

0:03:50.824,0:03:52.384
and the same as a gorilla.

0:03:52.408,0:03:53.878
(Laughter)

0:03:55.365,0:03:58.341
You can't see these things,[br]but they are very strange.

0:03:58.365,0:04:01.058
The stars by day, I always[br]think that's fascinating.

0:04:01.082,0:04:02.387
The universe disappears.

0:04:02.411,0:04:04.687
The more light there is,[br]the less you can see.

0:04:05.811,0:04:08.180
Time. Nobody can see time.

0:04:08.204,0:04:09.673
I don't know if you know this.

0:04:09.697,0:04:12.424
There's a big movement in modern physics

0:04:12.448,0:04:14.458
to decide that time doesn't really exist,

0:04:14.482,0:04:16.789
because it's too inconvenient[br]for the figures.

0:04:16.813,0:04:18.839
It's much easier if it's not really there.

0:04:18.863,0:04:21.223
You can't see the future, obviously,

0:04:21.247,0:04:23.943
and you can't see the past,[br]except in your memory.

0:04:23.967,0:04:26.030
One of the interesting[br]things about the past

0:04:26.054,0:04:27.673
is you particularly can't see --

0:04:27.697,0:04:29.373
my son asked me this the other day,

0:04:29.397,0:04:31.936
"Dad, can you remember[br]what I was like when I was two?

0:04:31.960,0:04:33.968
And I said, "Yes." He said, "Why can't I?"

0:04:33.992,0:04:35.184
Isn't that extraordinary?

0:04:35.208,0:04:39.294
You cannot remember what happened to you[br]earlier than the age of two or three.

0:04:39.318,0:04:43.159
Which is great news for psychoanalysts,[br]because otherwise they'd be out of a job.

0:04:43.183,0:04:45.595
Because that's where all the stuff happens

0:04:45.619,0:04:48.064
(Laughter)

0:04:48.088,0:04:49.728
that makes you who you are.

0:04:51.359,0:04:54.145
Another thing you can't see[br]is the grid on which we hang.

0:04:54.169,0:04:55.192
This is fascinating.

0:04:55.216,0:04:58.689
You probably know, some of you,[br]that cells are continually renewed.

0:04:58.713,0:05:01.891
Skin flakes off, hairs grow,[br]nails, that kind of stuff --

0:05:01.915,0:05:05.024
but every cell in your body[br]is replaced at some point.

0:05:05.048,0:05:07.491
Taste buds, every ten days or so.

0:05:07.515,0:05:10.258
Livers and internal organs[br]take a bit longer.

0:05:10.282,0:05:11.908
Spine takes several years.

0:05:11.932,0:05:15.463
But at the end of seven years,[br]not one cell in your body

0:05:15.487,0:05:18.275
remains from what was there[br]seven years ago.

0:05:18.299,0:05:21.088
The question is:[br]who then are we? What are we?

0:05:21.112,0:05:23.123
What is this thing that we hang on?

0:05:23.147,0:05:24.680
That is actually us?

0:05:24.704,0:05:27.812
Atoms, can't see them. Nobody ever will.

0:05:27.836,0:05:29.973
They're smaller[br]than the wavelength of light.

0:05:29.997,0:05:31.268
Gas, can't see that.

0:05:31.292,0:05:33.633
Interesting, somebody[br]mentioned 1600 recently.

0:05:33.657,0:05:37.434
Gas was invented in 1600[br]by a Dutch chemist called van Helmont.

0:05:38.448,0:05:43.825
It's said to be the most successful ever[br]invention of a word by a known individual.

0:05:43.849,0:05:49.340
Quite good. He also invented a word[br]called "blas," meaning astral radiation.

0:05:49.364,0:05:51.253
Didn't catch on, unfortunately.

0:05:51.277,0:05:52.278
(Laughter)

0:05:52.302,0:05:53.373
But well done, him.

0:05:53.397,0:05:55.598
Light -- you can't see light.

0:05:55.622,0:05:57.036
When it's dark, in a vacuum,

0:05:57.060,0:05:59.225
if a person shines a beam of light

0:05:59.249,0:06:01.480
straight across your eyes,[br]you won't see it.

0:06:01.504,0:06:04.348
Slightly technical, some physicists[br]will disagree with this.

0:06:04.372,0:06:06.713
But it's odd that you can't see[br]the beam of light,

0:06:06.737,0:06:08.222
you can only see what it hits.

0:06:08.246,0:06:09.603
Electricity, can't see that.

0:06:09.627,0:06:12.771
Don't let anyone tell you[br]they understand electricity, they don't.

0:06:12.795,0:06:13.957
Nobody knows what it is.

0:06:13.981,0:06:14.988
(Laughter)

0:06:15.012,0:06:18.520
You probably think the electrons[br]in an electric wire move instantaneously

0:06:18.544,0:06:20.934
down a wire, don't you,[br]at the speed of light,

0:06:20.958,0:06:23.030
when you turn the light on, they don't.

0:06:23.054,0:06:24.697
Electrons bumble down the wire,

0:06:24.721,0:06:27.109
about the speed of spreading[br]honey, they say.

0:06:27.133,0:06:28.868
Galaxies -- hundred billion of them,

0:06:28.892,0:06:30.974
estimated in the universe.[br]Hundred billion.

0:06:30.998,0:06:32.345
How many can we see?

0:06:32.369,0:06:36.041
Five. Five, out of a hundred billion[br]galaxies, with the naked eye.

0:06:36.065,0:06:39.828
And one of them is quite difficult to see,[br]unless you've got very good eyesight.

0:06:39.852,0:06:41.541
Radio waves. There's another thing.

0:06:41.565,0:06:44.752
Heinrich Hertz, when he discovered[br]radio waves, in 1887,

0:06:44.776,0:06:47.158
he called them radio waves[br]because they radiated.

0:06:47.182,0:06:50.017
Somebody said to him,[br]"What's the point of these, Heinrich?

0:06:50.041,0:06:52.750
What's the point of these radio waves[br]that you've found?"

0:06:52.774,0:06:54.369
And he said, "Well, I've no idea,

0:06:54.393,0:06:56.976
but I guess somebody will find[br]a use for them someday.

0:06:57.000,0:07:00.037
The biggest thing that's invisible[br]to us is what we don't know.

0:07:00.061,0:07:02.974
It is incredible how little we know.

0:07:02.998,0:07:04.297
Thomas Edison once said,

0:07:04.321,0:07:08.924
"We don't know one percent[br]of one millionth about anything."

0:07:08.948,0:07:12.090
And I've come to the conclusion --

0:07:12.114,0:07:15.584
because you ask this other question:[br]"What's another thing we can't see?"

0:07:15.608,0:07:17.557
The point, most of us. What's the point?

0:07:17.581,0:07:19.343
The point -- what I've got it down to

0:07:19.367,0:07:21.867
is there are only two questions[br]really worth asking.

0:07:21.891,0:07:22.903
"Why are we here?",

0:07:22.927,0:07:25.448
and "What should[br]we do about it while we are?"

0:07:25.472,0:07:29.509
To help you, I've got two things to leave[br]you with, from two great philosophers,

0:07:29.533,0:07:32.819
perhaps two of the greatest philosopher[br]thinkers of the 20th century.

0:07:32.843,0:07:35.609
One a mathematician and engineer,[br]and the other a poet.

0:07:35.633,0:07:38.423
The first is Ludwig Wittgenstein,

0:07:38.447,0:07:41.229
who said, "I don't know why we are here,

0:07:41.253,0:07:44.109
but I am pretty sure it's not[br]in order to enjoy ourselves."

0:07:44.133,0:07:45.165
(Laughter)

0:07:45.189,0:07:47.092
He was a cheerful bastard, wasn't he?

0:07:47.116,0:07:48.282
(Laughter)

0:07:48.306,0:07:53.804
And secondly, and lastly,[br]W.H. Auden, one of my favorite poets,

0:07:53.828,0:07:58.439
who said, "We are here[br]on Earth to help others.

0:07:58.463,0:08:01.857
What the others[br]are here for, I've no idea."

0:08:01.881,0:08:03.400
(Laughter)

0:08:03.424,0:08:06.079
(Applause)

0:08:06.103,0:08:07.274
(Circus music)

0:08:07.298,0:08:08.958
[Get your souvenir photo here!]

0:08:08.982,0:08:11.738
[Continue your journey into the unknown!]

0:08:11.762,0:08:13.788
(Circus music)