then in addition to being super Isabel made a nice transition but with CNPV to this question the democratic that is to say finally what interested me in what I heard you say many times this is to say that finally what interested me in what I heard you say many times this is to say that and a kind of cause of causes and if we can not change all that maybe there is a problem in the way we organize together is what you can tell us more hello to all it appears that the collective brain which I participate my side for some time I too am a hummingbird that is to say, I do what I can we do what we can and in this collective brain is being put in highlight , to see a series of ... highlight , to see a series of ... how to tell lies or errors as you want but good , say error on significant words that prevent us from that prevent us to imagine the solutions radical solutions that no words to take root it all started ... I must go quickly so I'll go fast ... it all started in 2005 on the occasion of this debate on the anticonstitution European I call it like this Now , I do not know ca at the time still European I call it like this Now , I do not know ca at the time still I thought it was at the time a poor European constitution because I ... I read in the I could see that the text we not protected but we imprisoned that this starting point of my reflection which woke me what I transformed into a hummingbird so this adventure then this hazard m led on the track the constitution, the law I am a lawyer by training so that leads me to go naturally it seems to me that the common point all resistant to all those who brawl against injustice social ecological, but not only that can be financial, social, in the enterprise corruption responsible etcaetera different social injustices I find that activists resistant share their impotence. we together, our common cause even if it feels very different our common cause is our i.e. political impotence that even if there s apply even if we are very very many millions in the street we come not to change essentially on unable to regain control of policy we come not to regain control our decisions collective we know very well by our members just by our experts who spend their time to focus on a subject, become very sharp on the very sharp nuclear the energy renewable , very sharp on the financial disaster , very sharp on the labor law which we need to protect ourselves from owners et cetera et cetera even with , thanks to these donors alert through these resistant even with alternatives for everything you need make it better it seems that we run into a wall of impotence which same for all of us it seems that we run into a wall of impotence which same for all of us and none of us and this is what I imagine we should change none of us and this is what I imagine we should change none of us n try to understand but but where it comes from is what it is is that it is a law that falls from heaven this is what political impotence it is always true that the observed and everywhere is observed in all the countries world and at all times , peoples are subject to teachers who decides everything for them they are left in the best If the possibility of designating these masters by so-called falsely universal suffrage universal suffrage for me is a vote ourselves the laws we consent and therefore there called universal suffrage merely designate our masters and more from people we do not even chosen which are selected by the richest those who can afford to buy TVs and newspapers our ... in our collective brain we did the week last correlation between the number of hours spent watching TV before the elections the election results incredible c is absolutely perfect you have points a curve corresponding exactly when you reconcile the scales exactly the correlation is perfect one to be elected is one who went on TV this is not the one who is the most virtuous this is not one that is most brave, this is not one who has the best values , who sy splint most he who seeks the best public interest , who listens to others and is patient, must stop ca n has nothing to do with it one to be elected is one who went on TV So what is important politics with false universal suffrage is to designate masters among those that were not selected what matters it has TV nice it's called democracy I I we doing to us we see that have put out on television and we Let's learn who we talk to on Internet and then we'll see in meetings we are us see that we got smoke the word democracy then few other words ESSENTIAL I call liars and words that are the really important words if we the re appropriate those we considered utopias become political projects feasible they were utopias because they had all words upside and we agreed to use the wrong example we call democracy the people power a system in which the people did not power I 'll just make a break to vary the pleasures I'll just give you a sentence that I like a lot because when I discovered that I discovered that c is thought of as this from the beginning this is not a accident is not a drift is not a regime that was good which became bad it is a regime that has been designed from departure as it is today i.e. a diet rich for the rich by rich I will read you a quote Sieyes was a "great thinker of the French Revolution " forgiveness large I mean historical a scoundrel sold, corrupt , which has filled the pockets of gold that he gave Napoleon later I not going to argue but in any case Sieyes is one of the great thinkers One of the most important thinkers , not a second knife of the French Revolution wrote this SMS : "Citizens who call themselves representatives waive and must give to the law themselves they have no particular desire to impose s they decided what the wills France be it more this state it would be a state representative democratic the people I say , " always said Sieyes " in a country that is not democracy " in September 1789 therefore , " not a democracy " between brackets " and not France be the people can not speak can not act that its representatives " you not tell me that representatives serve people they know from the start very well that they want to they want to take it to the people they pretend to be servants of the people and in fact they also mastered before French revolution j ' have another small it comes from Voltaire therefore , Voltaire died al time of the French revolution , it just died with Rousseau , and Voltaire had written few words, you have as c is picked his philosophy is same as that will end up with Sieyes and designers of our plans and current sponsors of our pension follow the same moral voltaire voltaire for the moral good of society that is organized where the small number actually work the large number is fed by him and government That is the moral of voltaire we are supposed to learn at school as the alpha and omega I and I learned as the alpha and omega of the virtue of tolerance goodness , progress democracy my eye! voltaire make a good icon for arms dealers for people who are fattened selling weapons, voltaire selling weapons I learned much later ca Voltaire was a supplier to the armed I have not developed - what are we can etienne if you had to descend into something which is good for us and that we ca said like we could do together then it was discovered that in fact it reopens the doors. unlike the it's true we could read what I say but saying .. though he speaks a lie words to practice but to positively and what we do but attention to what I tell you it gives me full hopes if I had ... that's right yes if I had to rely on virtue political actors under the elected today if you do not now see you 'll ever site that serve only banks that do not serve the people; serving banks banks that have elected this is normal so do not blame them they are in their role and returns lift to those to whom they owe their power us they owe nothing you understand curves, they must their power to those who pass on TV and they s us they tap n have nothing to do voters you understand what counts is the transition to TV so if I wait if I wait these political actors under I'll wait a long time if I wait written by these democracy folks it never happens Yet that there are good people in there , there are people who toil among elected people who seek to serve the general interest I do not say they are all rotten this is not what I say I ds when they write the constitution that is to say, when writing the text higher I would not have time develop 'll have to go see the net detail but when they write that top text that they should fear to protect us all we needs a constitution that is to say a superior text that will protect us all tyrants tyrants anyone we do not know but which still good constitution it should it should be if it is us who wrote it should protect us against tyrants tyrants all or is it that the text we let write idiots we are Finally, we are unaware ignorant not yet awakened us we let write constitution by the very people who ought to fear I think everything is there it is not antagonistic with this I heard tonight is I think the additional Best resistant need integrate their software into priorities in that in addition to having detected monetary scuttling more have spotted scuttling energy besides having spotted scuttling in our education etcaetera besides having spotted each each social injustices their causes and solutions should we re- appropriating the constituent process it takes more than they are the professionals policy people we need but which should not write constitution requires more than it is they who in the process are then constituting how to practice must you first that we very many have understood it is there that plays our Impotence is when when we accept a professional policy write the text that should be feared to protect myself in addition to its potential abuse of power so when I give here I realize and possible future very predictable political impotence when I spotted this place where I spotted among all causes of my helplessness I spotted a cause important . Hippocrates was a physician we said to look for the cause of causes because when you are sick it is nothing to attack symptoms we must seek the cause of disease when we found the cause and that is attacking the cause it solves the problem it's the same to us if one takes the waste or poor nuclear decision and that they say this is very bad nuclear decision you can protest all you want but it is not at all the cause is a consequence I think if we take the problem if each of us trying to trace the cause of our powerlessness despite the need for is given the efforts that it arrives not to change things we will all converge to a point is the same that is instituting organize our first power by writing ourselves the constitution then be played after écrivonsd'abord , we regroup on , it has two advantages 1 . d we first met we stop arguing they found a common cause and 2 . instead a consequence of c is cause it is smarter we will be more effective by in taking a case to a result on one stone two birds with more it becomes millions fight a common thing instituting our first power on is bagarrera on details about what we do how are we doing so far if you do a referendum in the street it will not work most people are good will say if you ask them questions we need a Constituent Assembly elected so it's normal they are told ca all day to TV on the radio we repeat the democracy is the election and the election this is democracy I hurry I'm sorry I can hold seven hours then really I must be careful I must get to keep just the best and most important but the most important is that for that to happen to it happens that we become a constituent people is to say establishing our power instead of leave establish our powerlessness other of political professionals was no need for professionals policy to make it happen we need wanted for that we want we need to be form us these jokes popular education which we need it is useless to expect you understand whether elected officials who shape us media form we professionals of this that it is nothing it is up to us to form between we the base is expecting nothing of our masters you basically happens when the word out there waiting there something that The important thing is that the next Constituent Assembly it should not be elected it must be raffled or that s there who are afraid of the draw but hey we could discuss the fears that it makes you none is founded the draw with controls that go with has any power for us protect against abuse of power more protective than the election and illusory confidence that not work 200 years of experience election n ' gave the power, since 1789 200 years of elections have always given power to the rich! there is a or two exceptions , nothing whatever always power to the rich while 200 years raffle to athens I do not have time to develop but it is that which has 200 years of drawing lot in Athens - hopefully tonight anyway - 200 years raffle it is the poor who ruled without stop for 200 years but I it I did that moves this thing that these are facts I say but how long if the draw empowers poor poor us c is c is 99 % if the draw controlled lce is not drawn to vote the law is that we vote the the law drawn we make services needed if the draw political retains the power to the people and gives power to the people and if the election empowers rich conbien time yet 99% we will defend this false universal suffrage as the alpha and omega of how our freedom time that is the question the last word we should actually I am discovering , I'm good conferences for a year or two years more I meet a lot of people I don not stop to progress but I also discovered that there is something that works better than the conference is the workshop component tomorrow not tomorrow but I actually with a masters ignorant paris and I actually another in Vercors Saturday it's great that thing what we do we get together we can be 10 be 20 can be 2 or 3 and we will talk about we will set up our social contract we will we will check that it is possible for example what we lack the popular initiative referendum yeah it's true that it holds in three lines and it suffices to write and you can even prick countries neighbors and then when we fall into the country neighbor we look at how he did it they say it's not bad but still it put first paragraph referendum popular initiative established second paragraph except of with the exception of taxes ( like why did they put the taxes ) and al exception of treaties it's not complicated if you do that you turn into action what the departure is the idea must go a sentence and you'll see that it anchor in you the idea that it is possible and it is much better people whose job it is not may very well written good constitution people that this is not the trade may well write a constitution and because it is not their business they write very good constitution for everyone - Voila - thank you ! we will stop