WEBVTT

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:05.388
♪ [music] ♪

00:00:14.779 --> 00:00:17.634
- [Alex] A modern economy
depends on the cooperation

00:00:17.634 --> 00:00:19.977
of vast numbers of strangers,

00:00:19.977 --> 00:00:22.493
but how is this cooperation
coordinated?

00:00:22.969 --> 00:00:25.337
Let's revisit the economics
behind roses,

00:00:25.337 --> 00:00:28.095
but this time,
let's go back to 1973.

00:00:28.522 --> 00:00:33.018
In the 1970s, the price of oil
skyrocketed so it made sense

00:00:33.018 --> 00:00:36.764
to economize --
but oil has many uses.

00:00:37.439 --> 00:00:41.729
So which uses should we cut back
and which should we maintain?

00:00:43.157 --> 00:00:47.387
In a market economy, no one person
decides these questions

00:00:47.387 --> 00:00:51.354
or perhaps more accurately,
everyone does.

00:00:51.354 --> 00:00:54.827
A price is a signal
wrapped up in an incentive.

00:00:55.434 --> 00:00:59.258
So when the price of oil increased,
it signaled that oil

00:00:59.258 --> 00:01:02.255
had become more scarce
and it gave everyone

00:01:02.255 --> 00:01:05.547
an incentive to listen
to that signal.

00:01:05.547 --> 00:01:09.905
It said, "Find ways
to economize on oil

00:01:09.905 --> 00:01:13.475
or develop substitutes
and you will profit."

00:01:13.475 --> 00:01:15.440
When the price of oil
first increased,

00:01:15.440 --> 00:01:17.685
most roses bought
in the United States were grown

00:01:17.685 --> 00:01:21.339
in greenhouses in New Jersey,
in Pennsylvania.

00:01:21.339 --> 00:01:24.447
The increased price of oil
meant that it cost more

00:01:24.447 --> 00:01:28.135
to heat those greenhouses,
which meant a shift upwards

00:01:28.135 --> 00:01:32.002
in the supply curve for flowers
and an increase in the price.

00:01:32.643 --> 00:01:34.823
The result was that
it encouraged people

00:01:34.823 --> 00:01:37.102
to turn to substitutes.

00:01:37.102 --> 00:01:40.492
Such as chocolate and Teddy bears
to give to their loved ones

00:01:40.492 --> 00:01:44.103
at Valentine's Day --
but the story doesn't end there.

00:01:44.752 --> 00:01:48.116
Seeing the higher price of oil,
entrepreneurs began to think

00:01:48.116 --> 00:01:50.523
about other ways
to produce flowers.

00:01:51.126 --> 00:01:54.713
Instead of heating a greenhouse,
why not use the natural heat

00:01:54.713 --> 00:01:57.181
of the sun and transport the roses.

00:01:57.931 --> 00:02:01.619
Entrepreneurs encouraged farmers
in Kenya and Ecuador

00:02:01.619 --> 00:02:03.453
to start growing roses.

00:02:03.453 --> 00:02:06.828
And they began to invest
in a new global infrastructure

00:02:06.828 --> 00:02:09.402
to deliver roses around the world.

00:02:10.202 --> 00:02:11.703
Who could have predicted it?

00:02:11.703 --> 00:02:14.821
That one way of adjusting
to a reduced supply of oil

00:02:14.821 --> 00:02:17.398
was greater consumption
of chocolate?

00:02:17.398 --> 00:02:20.260
And another way,
was by importing roses.

00:02:20.260 --> 00:02:23.513
In fact, no one
could have predicted,

00:02:23.513 --> 00:02:27.854
let alone plan all the myriad ways
in which people responded

00:02:27.854 --> 00:02:29.771
to the increased price of oil.

00:02:30.262 --> 00:02:33.283
That's because no one knows
all the information

00:02:33.283 --> 00:02:35.024
that the market uses.

00:02:35.024 --> 00:02:37.588
Everything from the cost
of growing greenhouses,

00:02:37.588 --> 00:02:40.570
to the demand for roses
versus chocolate,

00:02:40.570 --> 00:02:42.642
to the value
that a particular piece

00:02:42.642 --> 00:02:46.902
of land in Kenya has
for growing flowers versus coffee.

00:02:47.551 --> 00:02:51.317
No single individual
knows all of this information.

00:02:51.317 --> 00:02:52.839
It's dispersed.

00:02:52.839 --> 00:02:57.465
So when oil becomes scarce,
we want people all over the world

00:02:57.465 --> 00:03:01.731
to use this dispersed information,
their information

00:03:01.731 --> 00:03:06.669
and their ingenuity to figure out
how best to economize on oil.

00:03:07.381 --> 00:03:10.726
The price system does this
in a remarkably efficient way.

00:03:11.519 --> 00:03:15.141
The Kenyan farmer doesn't have
to know anything about oil

00:03:15.141 --> 00:03:17.889
to have an incentive
to do the right thing.

00:03:18.421 --> 00:03:22.688
He just sees that the price paid
for roses has increased

00:03:22.688 --> 00:03:26.261
and so following his self interest,
he starts to produce more roses.

00:03:27.743 --> 00:03:32.168
Ultimately, that frees up more oil
to be used in the production

00:03:32.168 --> 00:03:35.054
of jet fuel where there
are fewer substitutes.

00:03:35.752 --> 00:03:39.905
Millions of decisions like this
made all over the world,

00:03:39.905 --> 00:03:43.163
rearrange and reallocate
the world's production.

00:03:43.163 --> 00:03:47.096
Taking oil from where
it has low value and moving it

00:03:47.096 --> 00:03:51.406
to where it has high value
so that we produce the most value

00:03:51.406 --> 00:03:53.495
from our limited resources.

00:03:53.920 --> 00:03:56.911
That is the invisible
hand in action.

00:03:57.530 --> 00:03:59.860
If it had been invented,
the price system

00:03:59.860 --> 00:04:03.636
would be one of the most amazing
creations of the human mind.

00:04:04.174 --> 00:04:07.283
But like language,
it wasn't invented,

00:04:07.283 --> 00:04:11.030
and it worked long before
anyone had any understanding

00:04:11.030 --> 00:04:12.797
of its principles.

00:04:12.797 --> 00:04:16.538
As Nobel Prize winning economist,
Vernon Smith, has put it,

00:04:16.538 --> 00:04:20.857
"The pricing system
is a scientific mystery as deep,

00:04:20.857 --> 00:04:25.579
fundamental, and inspiring
as that of the expanding universe

00:04:25.579 --> 00:04:27.933
or the forces that bind matter."

00:04:27.933 --> 00:04:30.620
We'll be exploring more
about the mystery

00:04:30.620 --> 00:04:33.527
and the marvel of the price system
in the next video.

00:04:34.407 --> 00:04:36.061
- [Narrator] If you want
to test yourself,

00:04:36.061 --> 00:04:38.363
click "Practice Questions."

00:04:38.363 --> 00:04:41.614
Or if you're ready to move on,
just click "Next Video."

00:04:41.614 --> 00:04:46.781
♪ [music] ♪