0:00:08.744,0:00:13.883


0:00:13.883,0:00:19.039


0:00:19.039,0:00:25.821


0:00:25.821,0:00:31.407


0:00:31.407,0:00:39.702


0:00:39.702,0:00:47.122


0:00:47.122,0:00:53.073


0:00:53.073,0:01:01.489


0:01:01.489,0:01:11.045


0:01:11.045,0:01:18.076


0:01:18.076,0:01:20.826


0:01:20.826,0:01:24.291


0:01:24.291,0:01:31.993


0:01:31.993,0:01:37.662


0:01:37.662,0:01:45.661


0:01:45.661,0:01:54.407


0:01:54.407,0:02:03.074


0:02:03.074,0:02:12.173


0:02:12.173,0:02:18.369


0:02:18.369,0:02:26.816


0:02:26.816,0:02:37.435


0:02:37.435,0:02:43.772


0:02:43.772,0:02:49.362


0:02:49.362,0:02:53.880


0:02:53.880,0:03:00.542


0:03:00.542,0:03:08.096


0:03:08.096,0:03:13.937


0:03:13.937,0:03:19.961


0:03:19.961,0:03:27.278


0:03:27.278,0:03:30.354


0:03:30.354,0:03:35.603


0:03:35.603,0:03:39.609


0:03:39.609,0:03:51.024


0:03:51.024,0:03:59.346


0:03:59.346,0:04:05.778


0:04:05.778,0:04:12.941


0:04:12.941,0:04:21.133


0:04:21.133,0:04:26.297


0:04:26.297,0:04:35.205


0:04:35.205,0:04:40.751


0:04:40.751,0:04:46.962


0:04:46.962,0:04:55.416


0:04:55.416,0:04:57.661


0:04:57.661,0:05:04.811


0:05:04.811,0:05:12.538


0:05:12.538,0:05:19.123


0:05:19.123,0:05:24.621


0:05:24.621,0:05:31.377


0:05:31.377,0:05:40.792


0:05:40.792,0:05:47.463


0:05:47.463,0:05:53.550


0:05:53.550,0:06:02.045


0:06:02.045,0:06:09.499


0:06:09.499,0:06:16.749


0:06:16.749,0:06:25.592


0:06:25.592,0:06:32.171


0:06:32.171,0:06:39.694


0:06:39.694,0:06:46.536


0:06:46.536,0:06:55.978


0:06:55.978,0:07:00.740


0:07:00.740,0:07:08.659


0:07:08.659,0:07:19.511


0:07:19.511,0:07:27.791


0:07:27.791,0:07:38.155


0:07:38.155,0:07:45.593


0:07:45.593,0:07:59.397


0:07:59.397,0:08:05.526


0:08:05.526,0:08:15.102


0:08:15.102,0:08:21.941


0:08:21.941,0:08:27.727


0:08:27.727,0:08:35.479


0:08:35.479,0:08:40.258


0:08:40.258,0:08:47.369


0:08:47.369,0:08:59.735


0:08:59.735,0:09:07.509


0:09:07.509,0:09:18.813


0:09:18.813,0:09:27.400


0:09:27.400,0:09:36.735


0:09:36.735,0:09:40.903


0:09:40.903,0:09:48.982


0:09:48.982,0:10:03.489


0:10:03.489,0:10:12.311


0:10:12.311,0:10:22.418


0:10:22.418,0:10:32.803


0:10:32.803,0:10:40.035


0:10:40.035,0:10:49.622


0:10:49.622,0:10:54.995


0:10:54.995,0:11:07.246


0:11:07.246,0:11:17.667


0:11:17.667,0:11:30.530


0:11:30.530,0:11:41.664


0:11:41.664,0:11:52.923


0:11:52.923,0:11:58.011


0:11:58.011,0:12:05.923


0:12:05.923,0:12:16.554


0:12:16.554,0:12:22.173


0:12:22.173,0:12:34.645


0:12:34.645,0:12:42.725


0:12:42.725,0:12:49.099


0:12:49.099,0:13:02.978


0:13:02.978,0:13:10.461


0:13:10.461,0:13:19.607


0:13:19.607,0:13:27.145


0:13:27.145,0:13:36.424


0:13:36.424,0:13:43.011


0:13:43.011,0:13:48.357


0:13:48.357,0:13:58.182


0:13:58.182,0:14:06.488


0:14:06.488,0:14:15.561


0:14:15.561,0:14:22.505


0:14:22.505,0:14:31.269


0:14:31.269,0:14:37.883


0:14:37.883,0:14:44.967


0:14:44.967,0:14:58.075


0:14:58.075,0:15:06.993


0:15:06.993,0:15:10.827


0:15:10.827,0:15:20.128


0:15:20.128,0:15:33.240


0:15:33.240,0:15:38.871


0:15:38.871,0:15:53.246


0:15:53.246,0:16:01.135


0:16:01.135,0:16:10.493


0:16:10.493,0:16:20.231


0:16:20.231,0:16:25.822


0:16:25.822,0:16:35.734


0:16:35.734,0:16:41.971


0:16:41.971,0:16:50.849


0:16:50.849,0:16:58.309


0:16:58.309,0:17:04.117


0:17:04.117,0:17:10.943


0:17:10.943,0:17:19.635


0:17:19.635,0:17:26.853


0:17:26.853,0:17:31.661


0:17:31.661,0:17:41.446


0:17:41.446,0:17:49.309


0:17:49.309,0:17:55.689


0:17:55.689,0:18:05.549


0:18:05.549,0:18:12.165


0:18:12.165,0:18:23.266


0:18:23.266,0:18:32.876


0:18:32.876,0:18:39.550


0:18:39.550,0:18:48.368


0:18:48.368,0:18:59.679


0:18:59.679,0:19:07.119


0:19:07.119,0:19:17.999


0:19:17.999,0:19:25.841


0:19:25.841,0:19:35.840


0:19:35.840,0:19:47.725


0:19:47.725,0:19:54.059


0:19:54.059,0:20:02.756


0:20:02.756,0:20:08.644


0:20:08.644,0:20:20.330


0:20:20.330,0:20:26.737


0:20:26.737,0:20:32.884


0:20:32.884,0:20:42.862


0:20:42.862,0:20:52.800


0:20:52.800,0:20:59.828


0:20:59.828,0:21:08.849


0:21:08.849,0:21:17.370


0:21:17.370,0:21:28.989


0:21:28.989,0:21:34.779


0:21:34.779,0:21:44.632


0:21:44.632,0:21:54.276


0:21:54.276,0:22:03.409


0:22:03.409,0:22:11.522


0:22:11.522,0:22:22.824


0:22:22.824,0:22:30.243


0:22:30.243,0:22:40.353


0:22:40.353,0:22:46.126


0:22:46.126,0:22:56.069


0:22:56.069,0:23:03.164


0:23:03.164,0:23:12.491


0:23:12.491,0:23:21.660


0:23:21.660,0:23:29.400


0:23:29.400,0:23:42.771


0:23:42.771,0:23:50.820


0:23:50.820,0:23:55.682


0:23:55.682,0:24:04.582


0:24:04.582,0:24:15.987


0:24:15.987,0:24:24.571


0:24:24.571,0:24:35.578


0:24:35.578,0:24:46.299


0:24:46.299,0:24:55.310


0:24:55.310,0:25:00.160


0:25:00.160,0:25:12.305


0:25:12.305,0:25:17.932


0:25:17.932,0:25:26.044


0:25:26.044,0:25:33.858


0:25:33.858,0:25:40.227


0:25:40.227,0:25:53.547


0:25:53.547,0:26:05.225


0:26:05.225,0:26:13.991


0:26:13.991,0:26:19.656


0:26:19.656,0:26:33.326


0:26:33.326,0:26:45.245


0:26:45.245,0:26:52.325


0:26:52.325,0:26:59.904


0:26:59.904,0:27:07.843


0:27:07.843,0:27:17.493


0:27:17.493,0:27:24.656


0:27:24.656,0:27:34.411


0:27:34.411,0:27:44.224


0:27:44.224,0:27:54.026


0:27:54.026,0:28:03.076


0:28:03.076,0:28:09.374


0:28:09.374,0:28:20.024


0:28:20.024,0:28:29.862


0:28:29.862,0:28:38.431


0:28:38.431,0:28:46.571


0:28:46.571,0:28:57.120


0:28:57.120,0:29:13.245


0:29:13.245,0:29:23.779


0:29:23.779,0:29:30.287


0:29:30.287,0:29:45.704


0:29:45.704,0:29:53.709


0:29:53.709,0:30:03.799


0:30:03.799,0:30:13.375


0:30:13.375,0:30:27.739


0:30:27.739,0:30:39.033


0:30:39.033,0:30:48.564


0:30:48.564,0:30:57.325


0:30:57.325,0:31:08.690


0:31:08.690,0:31:22.989


0:31:22.989,0:31:28.538


0:31:28.538,0:31:35.238


0:31:35.238,0:31:40.187


0:31:40.187,0:31:46.033


0:31:46.033,0:31:48.866


0:31:48.866,0:32:00.662


0:32:00.662,0:32:13.856


0:32:13.856,0:32:27.805


0:32:27.805,0:32:40.656


0:32:40.656,0:32:52.685


0:32:52.685,0:33:01.406


0:33:01.406,0:33:10.318


0:33:10.318,0:33:21.325


0:33:21.325,0:33:31.158


0:33:31.158,0:33:35.397


0:33:35.397,0:33:45.314


0:33:45.314,0:33:56.495


0:33:56.495,0:34:05.269


0:34:05.269,0:34:15.204


0:34:15.204,0:34:24.243


0:34:24.243,0:34:35.631


0:34:35.631,0:34:45.698


0:34:45.698,0:34:53.906


0:34:53.906,0:35:07.324


0:35:07.324,0:35:17.545


0:35:17.545,0:35:29.908


0:35:29.908,0:35:42.071


0:35:42.071,0:35:46.961


0:35:46.961,0:35:52.608


0:35:52.608,0:36:00.908


0:36:00.908,0:36:05.189


0:36:05.189,0:36:12.911


0:36:12.911,0:36:18.464


0:36:18.464,0:36:21.408


0:36:21.408,0:36:27.778


0:36:27.778,0:36:39.546


0:36:39.546,0:36:41.743


0:36:41.743,0:36:52.081


0:36:52.081,0:36:59.237


0:36:59.237,0:37:03.013


0:37:03.013,0:37:09.878


0:37:09.909,0:37:19.652


0:37:19.652,0:37:25.483


0:37:25.483,0:37:39.684


0:37:39.684,0:37:51.147


0:37:51.147,0:38:01.401


0:38:01.401,0:38:11.119


0:38:11.119,0:38:23.739


0:38:23.739,0:38:35.989


0:38:35.989,0:38:45.610


0:38:45.610,0:38:58.132


0:38:58.132,0:39:07.404


0:39:07.404,0:39:15.986


0:39:15.986,0:39:28.760


0:39:28.760,0:39:37.635


0:39:37.635,0:39:46.739


0:39:46.739,0:39:55.844


0:39:55.844,0:40:03.823


0:40:03.823,0:40:08.900


0:40:08.900,0:40:21.371


0:40:21.371,0:40:31.120


0:40:31.120,0:40:38.985


0:40:38.985,0:40:46.939


0:40:46.939,0:41:01.901


0:41:01.901,0:41:09.814


0:41:09.814,0:41:19.153


0:41:19.153,0:41:32.278


0:41:32.278,0:41:43.955


0:41:43.955,0:41:54.071


0:41:54.071,0:42:03.105


0:42:03.105,0:42:15.657


0:42:15.657,0:42:26.739


0:42:26.739,0:42:35.773


0:42:35.773,0:42:46.361


0:42:46.361,0:42:54.738


0:42:54.738,0:43:02.340


0:43:02.340,0:43:13.120


0:43:13.120,0:43:23.188


0:43:23.188,0:43:35.978


0:43:35.978,0:43:47.239


0:43:47.239,0:43:56.093


0:43:56.093,0:44:05.069


0:44:05.069,0:44:15.603


0:44:15.603,0:44:24.726


0:44:24.726,0:44:36.361


0:44:36.361,0:44:44.122


0:44:44.214,0:44:57.867


0:44:57.867,0:45:01.367


0:45:01.367,0:45:13.255


0:45:13.255,0:45:22.091


0:45:22.091,0:45:32.720


0:45:32.720,0:45:40.089


0:45:40.089,0:45:51.180


0:45:51.180,0:45:56.615


0:45:56.615,0:46:07.299


0:46:07.299,0:46:19.990


0:46:19.990,0:46:27.886


0:46:27.886,0:46:40.394


0:46:40.394,0:46:51.448


0:46:51.448,0:47:01.004


0:47:01.004,0:47:13.841


0:47:13.841,0:47:22.860


0:47:22.860,0:47:34.206


0:47:34.206,0:47:43.758


0:47:43.758,0:47:53.525


0:47:53.525,0:48:01.639


0:48:01.639,0:48:09.675


0:48:09.675,0:48:20.671


0:48:20.671,0:48:29.170


0:48:29.170,0:48:38.472


0:48:38.472,0:48:42.416


0:48:42.416,0:48:57.288


0:48:57.288,0:49:06.543


0:49:06.543,0:49:14.305


0:49:14.305,0:49:23.509


0:49:23.509,0:49:35.296


0:49:35.296,0:49:45.303


0:49:45.303,0:49:52.990


0:49:52.990,0:50:06.587


0:50:06.587,0:50:11.799


0:50:11.799,0:50:26.288


0:50:26.288,0:50:33.484


0:50:33.484,0:50:41.796


0:50:41.796,0:50:51.260


0:50:51.260,0:50:58.552


0:50:58.552,0:51:02.836


0:51:02.836,0:51:11.835


0:51:11.835,0:51:17.529


0:51:17.529,0:51:28.171
Au moment des premières révélations concernant Verizon et l'espionnage des téléphones portables, une des justifications avancées était – le Président l'a dit – :

0:51:28.171,0:51:38.449
« Ne vous en faites pas, il s'agit uniquement de métadonnées. Personne n'écoute vos conversations ». Je pense que c'est extrêmement.... Je ne trouve pas le mot...

0:51:38.449,0:51:45.343
-- Fourbe.[br]-- Oui, c'est ça. Parce que les métadonnées sont synonyme de surveillance.

0:51:45.343,0:51:55.034
Et c'est facile à comprendre. Imaginez que vous louiez les services d'un détective privé pour espionner quelqu’un. Ce détective cacherait un micro dans

0:51:55.034,0:52:03.613
le foyer, dans la voiture et dans le bureau de cette personne et vous obtiendriez le compte-rendu de ses conversations. Voilà ce que sont les données. Si vous demandez au même

0:52:03.613,0:52:14.955
détective privé de surveiller quelqu'un, vous auriez un compte-rendu différent : où il est allé, à qui il a parlé, ce qu'il a acheté, ce qu'il a lu. Tout cela sont les métadonnées.

0:52:14.955,0:52:25.009
Quand le Président dit : « Ne vous en faites pas, il s'agit uniquement de métadonnées », j'entends : « Ne vous en faites pas, vous êtes simplement sous surveillance 24 heures sur 24, 7 jours sur 7 ».

0:52:25.009,0:52:34.834


0:52:34.834,0:52:43.342


0:52:43.342,0:52:53.897


0:52:53.897,0:53:05.874


0:53:05.874,0:53:14.278


0:53:14.278,0:53:24.257


0:53:24.257,0:53:33.897


0:53:33.897,0:53:44.276


0:53:44.276,0:53:54.508


0:53:54.508,0:54:01.139


0:54:01.139,0:54:12.420


0:54:12.420,0:54:17.544


0:54:17.544,0:54:25.092


0:54:25.092,0:54:34.127


0:54:34.127,0:54:37.705


0:54:37.705,0:54:47.115


0:54:47.115,0:54:57.858


0:54:57.858,0:55:07.342


0:55:07.342,0:55:19.450


0:55:19.450,0:55:27.648


0:55:27.648,0:55:37.670


0:55:37.670,0:55:43.917


0:55:43.917,0:55:52.261


0:55:52.261,0:56:01.170


0:56:01.170,0:56:10.454


0:56:10.454,0:56:17.966


0:56:17.966,0:56:25.081


0:56:25.081,0:56:29.504


0:56:29.504,0:56:35.914


0:56:35.914,0:56:45.354


0:56:45.354,0:56:53.041


0:56:53.041,0:56:59.207


0:56:59.207,0:57:08.860


0:57:08.860,0:57:14.631


0:57:14.631,0:57:21.325


0:57:21.325,0:57:33.907


0:57:33.907,0:57:44.996


0:57:44.996,0:57:55.249


0:57:55.249,0:58:10.575


0:58:10.575,0:58:20.521


0:58:20.521,0:58:31.630


0:58:31.630,0:58:42.615


0:58:42.615,0:58:52.597


0:58:52.597,0:59:05.934


0:59:05.934,0:59:16.548


0:59:16.548,0:59:35.608


0:59:35.608,0:59:48.117


0:59:48.117,0:59:57.219


0:59:57.219,1:00:08.378


1:00:08.378,1:00:18.367


1:00:18.367,1:00:28.289


1:00:28.289,1:00:39.633


1:00:39.633,1:00:43.202


1:00:43.202,1:00:52.153


1:00:52.153,1:01:05.124


1:01:05.124,1:01:19.170


1:01:19.170,1:01:29.338


1:01:29.338,1:01:38.202


1:01:38.202,1:01:47.500


1:01:47.500,1:01:59.059


1:01:59.059,1:02:09.565


1:02:09.565,1:02:20.440


1:02:20.440,1:02:29.867


1:02:29.867,1:02:42.961


1:02:42.961,1:02:52.025


1:02:52.025,1:02:58.681


1:02:58.681,1:03:07.465


1:03:07.465,1:03:17.131


1:03:17.131,1:03:23.905


1:03:23.905,1:03:32.664


1:03:32.664,1:03:44.315


1:03:44.315,1:03:58.760


1:03:58.760,1:04:10.312


1:04:10.312,1:04:19.972


1:04:19.972,1:04:29.331


1:04:29.331,1:04:41.767


1:04:41.767,1:04:52.295


1:04:52.295,1:05:03.840


1:05:03.840,1:05:12.275


1:05:12.275,1:05:24.472


1:05:24.472,1:05:33.043


1:05:33.043,1:05:41.173


1:05:41.173,1:05:46.699


1:05:46.699,1:05:56.251


1:05:56.251,1:06:04.746


1:06:04.746,1:06:12.152


1:06:12.152,1:06:17.887


1:06:17.887,1:06:24.929


1:06:24.929,1:06:33.598


1:06:33.598,1:06:43.747


1:06:43.747,1:06:56.179


1:06:56.179,1:07:07.684


1:07:07.684,1:07:15.671


1:07:15.671,1:07:19.180


1:07:19.180,1:07:26.848


1:07:26.848,1:07:35.772


1:07:35.772,1:07:44.974


1:07:44.974,1:07:50.836


1:07:50.836,1:07:59.744


1:07:59.744,1:08:13.623


1:08:13.623,1:08:18.326


1:08:18.326,1:08:34.584


1:08:34.584,1:08:41.079


1:08:41.079,1:08:50.972


1:08:50.972,1:08:59.710


1:08:59.710,1:09:08.821


1:09:08.821,1:09:19.451


1:09:19.451,1:09:31.043


1:09:31.043,1:09:40.195


1:09:40.195,1:09:47.420


1:09:47.420,1:10:00.553


1:10:00.553,1:10:09.008


1:10:09.008,1:10:18.348


1:10:18.348,1:10:28.321


1:10:28.321,1:10:34.727


1:10:34.727,1:10:42.911


1:10:42.911,1:10:47.382


1:10:47.382,1:11:03.533


1:11:03.533,1:11:12.847


1:11:12.847,1:11:22.415


1:11:22.415,1:11:31.916


1:11:31.916,1:11:42.354


1:11:42.354,1:11:53.556


1:11:53.556,1:12:06.859


1:12:06.859,1:12:17.402


1:12:17.402,1:12:21.979


1:12:21.979,1:12:32.585


1:12:32.585,1:12:39.972


1:12:39.972,1:12:47.982


1:12:47.982,1:12:55.453


1:12:55.453,1:13:06.760


1:13:06.760,1:13:17.956


1:13:17.956,1:13:29.392


1:13:29.392,1:13:39.992


1:13:39.992,1:13:48.594


1:13:48.594,1:13:56.430


1:13:56.430,1:14:03.817


1:14:03.817,1:14:08.468


1:14:08.468,1:14:15.733


1:14:15.733,1:14:28.353


1:14:28.353,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000


9:59:59.000,9:59:59.000