WEBVTT

00:00:20.519 --> 00:00:27.041
Did you know that 15 minutes of stress
are enough to change the sex

00:00:27.041 --> 00:00:29.362
of some regions of the brain?

00:00:29.362 --> 00:00:36.911
From the male form to the female form
or from the female form to the male form?

00:00:36.911 --> 00:00:40.471
I didn't know that either,
but when I discovered this fact

00:00:40.471 --> 00:00:46.606
it transformed the way I was thinking
about sex and brain.

00:00:46.606 --> 00:00:48.692
It all started about four years ago

00:00:48.701 --> 00:00:52.243
when I decided to give a course
on the psychology of gender.

00:00:52.243 --> 00:00:56.583
I stayed home for almost a year
and read books and scientific papers

00:00:56.583 --> 00:01:01.253
on the development of men and women
from the moment of conception.

00:01:01.253 --> 00:01:04.068
As a neuroscientist I was,
of course, interested

00:01:04.068 --> 00:01:06.981
in the relation between sex and brain.

00:01:06.981 --> 00:01:11.474
I soon found out that many scientists,
just like most of us,

00:01:11.493 --> 00:01:14.813
believe that there are
male brains and female brains,

00:01:14.813 --> 00:01:18.160
and that this is the reason
for the fundamental differences

00:01:18.160 --> 00:01:20.630
between men and women.

00:01:20.639 --> 00:01:23.509
According to a very popular version
of this story,

00:01:23.518 --> 00:01:26.338
the female brain
has a large emotion center

00:01:26.338 --> 00:01:31.506
and a large communications center;
it is hard-wired for empathy.

00:01:31.506 --> 00:01:34.985
The male brain, on the other hand,
has a large aggression center,

00:01:34.985 --> 00:01:41.784
and a large sex center;
it is hard-wired for building systems.

00:01:41.784 --> 00:01:47.561
Maybe you thought of something else
but this is a scientific theory after all.

00:01:47.561 --> 00:01:49.879
(Laughter)

00:01:49.890 --> 00:01:53.962
This is a very popular theory or
very popular story, because it gives us

00:01:53.982 --> 00:01:57.490
a very simple explanation
to the world we live in.

00:01:57.494 --> 00:02:01.507
It explains why women are
more sensitive and emotional

00:02:01.507 --> 00:02:04.090
and men more aggressive and sexual.

00:02:04.098 --> 00:02:09.516
Why most teachers are women
and most engineers men.

00:02:09.516 --> 00:02:15.026
Already in the womb, the story continues,
the huge surge of testosterone

00:02:15.026 --> 00:02:18.400
transforms the brain of the male fetus

00:02:18.400 --> 00:02:21.972
from the default female form
to the male form.

00:02:21.972 --> 00:02:29.212
So boys are born with a male brain
and girls are born with a female brain.

00:02:29.220 --> 00:02:32.662
Whereas the notion of
a male brain and a female brain

00:02:32.662 --> 00:02:36.982
fits well the popular view of
men from Mars, women from Venus,

00:02:36.982 --> 00:02:41.746
it does not fit scientific data,
which tell us that men and women

00:02:41.746 --> 00:02:44.895
are remarkably similar.

00:02:44.895 --> 00:02:50.928
In the past 50 years or so,
over 50,000 papers have been published

00:02:50.928 --> 00:02:54.227
on sex differences in psychology.

00:02:54.227 --> 00:02:56.976
I haven't read them all,
even a year is not enough,

00:02:56.994 --> 00:03:02.621
but others have and their conclusion
based on this enormous number of studies

00:03:02.621 --> 00:03:05.556
is that men and women are highly similar

00:03:05.556 --> 00:03:08.887
in almost everything
psychologists can measure.

00:03:08.887 --> 00:03:11.765
Intellectual abilities,
cognitive abilities,

00:03:11.765 --> 00:03:15.121
emotional abilities,
personality characteristics,

00:03:15.121 --> 00:03:17.611
interest and attitudes.

00:03:17.616 --> 00:03:23.283
There are only a few domains in which
consistent sex differences are found.

00:03:23.283 --> 00:03:24.864
For example,

00:03:24.864 --> 00:03:28.785
men are on average, not all of them,
but on average, more aggressive

00:03:28.787 --> 00:03:33.079
than women.
So we call aggression a masculine trait.

00:03:33.079 --> 00:03:36.458
Women are on average
more compassionate than men,

00:03:36.458 --> 00:03:39.290
so we call this the feminine trait.

00:03:39.302 --> 00:03:46.063
But also in these domains
men and women are highly similar,

00:03:46.063 --> 00:03:49.733
and the differences are very small.

00:03:49.733 --> 00:03:56.343
Even more important, we now know
that each of us is a unique mosaic

00:03:56.356 --> 00:03:59.915
of both masculine and
feminine characteristics;

00:03:59.915 --> 00:04:05.575
we are not all masculine
and are not all feminine.

00:04:06.576 --> 00:04:09.310
I guess you already knew that,
not about me, but about yourself,

00:04:09.310 --> 00:04:13.930
that you have a feminine side
and a masculine side.

00:04:13.941 --> 00:04:17.295
I will come back to this image
of ourself as a unique mosaic

00:04:17.300 --> 00:04:20.433
of masculine and feminine characteristics
a little later.

00:04:20.442 --> 00:04:23.433
But now let's go back to the brain.

00:04:23.433 --> 00:04:26.123
Already at the end of the 19th century

00:04:26.123 --> 00:04:29.258
scientists discovered a difference
between the brains of men

00:04:29.280 --> 00:04:31.280
and the brains of women.

00:04:31.285 --> 00:04:34.957
They discovered that the brains of men
were on average larger

00:04:34.984 --> 00:04:37.107
than the brains of women.

00:04:37.107 --> 00:04:41.427
Some scientists took this as evidence
to support and explain

00:04:41.444 --> 00:04:46.151
the then widely held belief
that men are smarter than women.

00:04:46.151 --> 00:04:51.853
One scientist even went as far as stating
that women, because of the small brain,

00:04:51.853 --> 00:04:57.749
do not have the intellectual and academic
skills necessary for academic studies.

00:04:57.749 --> 00:05:01.012
If this logic sounds familiar,
this is not an accident.

00:05:01.012 --> 00:05:03.754
This is the same belief we started with,

00:05:03.754 --> 00:05:06.503
that men and women
are fundamentally different

00:05:06.503 --> 00:05:11.260
because men have male brains
and women have female brains.

00:05:11.265 --> 00:05:16.533
However this is an old version
of the myth, so it sounds absurd.

00:05:16.533 --> 00:05:19.869
Today, when women
not only go to universities,

00:05:19.869 --> 00:05:23.537
but outnumber men
at all level of academic studies,

00:05:23.537 --> 00:05:26.901
it sounds ridiculous
that scientists could have believed

00:05:26.906 --> 00:05:30.232
that women could not go to universities
because their brains

00:05:30.232 --> 00:05:34.091
were on average
smaller than the brains of men.

00:05:34.091 --> 00:05:36.144
Now don't get me wrong, women’s brains

00:05:36.144 --> 00:05:38.936
are still on average smaller
than men brains.

00:05:38.940 --> 00:05:41.700
What has changed is not
the size of the brain;

00:05:41.700 --> 00:05:46.518
what has changed is social norms
and laws that prohibited

00:05:46.518 --> 00:05:50.931
and disencouraged women from study.

00:05:51.098 --> 00:05:54.165
In the more than 100 years
that have passed

00:05:54.165 --> 00:05:56.851
scientists continue
to discover differences

00:05:56.851 --> 00:06:01.701
between the brains of males and females
in both humans and animals.

00:06:01.701 --> 00:06:08.873
For example, compared to men,
women have a thicker cortex,

00:06:08.877 --> 00:06:15.934
a higher proportion of grey matter,
and a lower proportion of white matter.

00:06:15.934 --> 00:06:19.877
Compared to women,
men have larger ventricles.

00:06:19.877 --> 00:06:22.575
These big holes you see in the brain.

00:06:22.582 --> 00:06:28.385
(Laughter)

00:06:28.638 --> 00:06:31.307
I see that some of you
that were very happy to discover

00:06:31.319 --> 00:06:34.242
about the fact
that men have bigger brains than women

00:06:34.256 --> 00:06:38.171
are not really happy with this discovery.

00:06:38.857 --> 00:06:41.471
And I can understand this
because if you believe,

00:06:41.471 --> 00:06:43.641
like the scientists
from the 19th century,

00:06:43.641 --> 00:06:46.256
that the size of the brain matters,

00:06:46.260 --> 00:06:50.084
then indeed you will be embarrassed
to discover that your bigger brains

00:06:50.084 --> 00:06:56.957
come together with the bigger --
what shall we call them? Empty spaces?

00:06:56.981 --> 00:07:01.772
But I want to convey the message
that this is all nonsense;

00:07:01.778 --> 00:07:05.814
men do just fine
with their larger ventricles.

00:07:05.814 --> 00:07:10.195
(Laughter)

00:07:10.195 --> 00:07:15.951
Just as women do just fine
with their smaller brains.

00:07:16.896 --> 00:07:22.111
We now know of hundreds of differences
between the brains of men and women.

00:07:22.111 --> 00:07:24.861
Not just differences in the size
as I've just shown you,

00:07:24.861 --> 00:07:27.304
but also differences
in the microanatomy of the brain

00:07:27.310 --> 00:07:29.881
and I'll show you an example shortly.

00:07:29.881 --> 00:07:32.737
And as more and more differences
have been discovered,

00:07:32.737 --> 00:07:35.963
the belief that there is a male brain
and a female brain

00:07:35.963 --> 00:07:38.577
has become stronger and stronger

00:07:38.577 --> 00:07:43.242
because everyone was taking for granted
the assumption that these differences

00:07:43.242 --> 00:07:48.539
were adding one to the other
as I've depicted in this figure.

00:07:48.539 --> 00:07:52.803
At first this sounded
completely logical to me;

00:07:52.803 --> 00:07:56.386
there are many differences between
the brains of males and females,

00:07:56.411 --> 00:08:00.726
so there must be a male brain
and a female brain.

00:08:00.726 --> 00:08:04.099
But then I read the paper
I told you about in the beginning,

00:08:04.099 --> 00:08:07.336
the one that found that stress
can change the sex of the brain,

00:08:07.336 --> 00:08:11.453
and I realized that this logic was flawed.

00:08:11.453 --> 00:08:14.433
Let's look at this study together.

00:08:14.433 --> 00:08:18.561
In this study the researchers
were interested in the effects of stress

00:08:18.561 --> 00:08:21.356
on a brain region called the hippocampus.

00:08:21.356 --> 00:08:24.316
They measured
the density of dendritic spines.

00:08:24.316 --> 00:08:28.710
You see here a neuron with its dendrite

00:08:28.710 --> 00:08:32.461
and the small red dots
are the dendritic spines.

00:08:32.461 --> 00:08:34.917
And here we can see an actual dendrite

00:08:34.917 --> 00:08:38.553
from a male rat
and a dendrite from a female rat,

00:08:38.555 --> 00:08:42.369
and I added red arrows
so it is easier to detect the spines.

00:08:42.369 --> 00:08:44.873
And we can clearly see a sex difference.

00:08:44.873 --> 00:08:49.204
Males have have fewer spines
compared to females.

00:08:49.204 --> 00:08:53.066
Cherish this moment, this is
the first time you actually get to see

00:08:53.068 --> 00:08:55.395
the sex difference in the brain.

00:08:55.395 --> 00:08:58.745
So we can say dendrites
in this region have a male form

00:08:58.745 --> 00:09:04.191
which is sparse spines
and a female form which is dense spines.

00:09:04.195 --> 00:09:06.771
There was another group of rats
in this study;

00:09:06.771 --> 00:09:09.497
these rats were stressed for 15 minutes;

00:09:09.497 --> 00:09:13.745
as long as this talk, so you can think
what is happening to my brain now.

00:09:13.745 --> 00:09:15.865
(Laughter)

00:09:15.872 --> 00:09:19.408
And here we can see
a dendrite from a stressed male

00:09:19.408 --> 00:09:22.316
and a dendrite from a stressed female.

00:09:22.327 --> 00:09:25.753
Strangely enough,
the dendrite from the stressed male

00:09:25.766 --> 00:09:31.371
has what we have just termed
the female form, that is, lots of spines.

00:09:31.371 --> 00:09:33.632
And the dendrite from the stressed female

00:09:33.632 --> 00:09:39.448
has what we have just termed
the male form, which is few spines.

00:09:39.449 --> 00:09:44.681
So we see that the form of dendrites
in this region depends on sex;

00:09:44.681 --> 00:09:52.331
it is different in males and in females.
But it does not depend only on sex.

00:09:52.331 --> 00:09:56.357
Knowing that the dendrite
you are looking at is from a female

00:09:56.357 --> 00:09:59.238
is not enough
to predict the form of the dendrite.

00:09:59.238 --> 00:10:02.278
whether you have few spines
or lots of spines.

00:10:02.301 --> 00:10:04.973
To predict this you also need to know

00:10:04.973 --> 00:10:09.470
whether this female was under stress
or wasn't.

00:10:09.470 --> 00:10:14.564
So though sex is important it is
interaction of sex and environment,

00:10:14.564 --> 00:10:21.216
in this case stress, that determines
the form of neurons in this region.

00:10:21.216 --> 00:10:24.582
As you may imagine,
I was very surprised by this study.

00:10:24.582 --> 00:10:27.601
So I started to look
for other similar studies.

00:10:27.601 --> 00:10:29.731
It wasn't really hard to find them.

00:10:29.731 --> 00:10:32.998
There were studies reporting
similar effects of stress

00:10:32.998 --> 00:10:38.379
when the stress was experienced in utero,
just after birth and in adulthood.

00:10:38.385 --> 00:10:41.762
There also similar effects
following other manipulations.

00:10:41.762 --> 00:10:46.942
For example, whether the rats were
housed individually or in groups,

00:10:46.942 --> 00:10:50.076
whether they had things to play with
or didn't.

00:10:50.089 --> 00:10:54.802
The different manipulations affected many
brain regions, not just the hippocampus.

00:10:54.809 --> 00:11:00.211
And many features of the brain
such as the size, number of neurons

00:11:00.216 --> 00:11:04.311
and dendritic morphology
as I've just shown.

00:11:04.311 --> 00:11:06.947
What was common to all of these studies

00:11:06.956 --> 00:11:10.333
was the finding that,
whatever the manipulation,

00:11:10.343 --> 00:11:16.666
some features of the brain
changed their sex and some didn't.

00:11:16.666 --> 00:11:20.070
You may be wondering now,
"So what is the meaning

00:11:20.070 --> 00:11:22.744
of talking about
the sex of a brain region,

00:11:22.748 --> 00:11:28.099
if we see that simple manipulations can
reverse what is male and what is female?"

00:11:28.099 --> 00:11:31.513
You are absolutely right,
it is meaningless

00:11:31.526 --> 00:11:34.631
to talk of the male form
and the female form.

00:11:34.639 --> 00:11:37.146
It makes much more sense,
it's much more reasonable

00:11:37.146 --> 00:11:42.299
and rational to use informative terms
such as sparse versus dense,

00:11:42.299 --> 00:11:45.829
high versus low, long versus short.

00:11:45.830 --> 00:11:49.265
But I will continue to use
this male-female terminology,

00:11:49.265 --> 00:11:53.330
because this will help me
make my point clear.

00:11:53.330 --> 00:11:56.458
Let's go back now to the male fetus,

00:11:56.458 --> 00:12:00.136
and to the testosterone surge
that is transforming his brain

00:12:00.136 --> 00:12:06.883
from the female form to the male form,
and not only one component, stress.

00:12:06.883 --> 00:12:11.862
Picture the fetus mother during
the long weeks of pregnancy.

00:12:11.866 --> 00:12:14.030
She sometimes experiences stress,

00:12:14.030 --> 00:12:17.764
not all the time,
but sometimes she experiences stress.

00:12:17.764 --> 00:12:25.125
Whenever she does some features
of her fetus brain change their sex.

00:12:25.125 --> 00:12:28.691
So when her boy is born,
his brain is a mosaic

00:12:28.703 --> 00:12:32.267
of both male and female characteristics.

00:12:32.279 --> 00:12:34.913
This mosaic is uniquely his.

00:12:34.913 --> 00:12:38.390
Molded by the complex interactions
of his hormones

00:12:38.406 --> 00:12:42.948
with the environment 
he has been living in up until now.

00:12:42.948 --> 00:12:46.987
The same is true for the female fetus.
Her brain is also molded

00:12:46.994 --> 00:12:50.607
by complex interactions
of hormones and environment,

00:12:50.613 --> 00:12:55.689
so that the little girl is also born
with the mosaic or brain mosaic

00:12:55.689 --> 00:12:59.792
composed of female
and male characteristics.

00:12:59.792 --> 00:13:01.598
So we see that we are already born

00:13:01.598 --> 00:13:05.864
with the brain
which is neither male nor female.

00:13:05.864 --> 00:13:12.791
It is intersex that is a mixture of both
male and female characteristics.

00:13:12.791 --> 00:13:18.413
This, or our, intersex brain will continue
to change throughout our life

00:13:18.413 --> 00:13:22.600
as a result of our unique experiences.

00:13:22.600 --> 00:13:26.759
We can now add to the image of ourselves
as a unique mosaic

00:13:26.759 --> 00:13:29.201
of masculine and feminine characteristics,

00:13:29.201 --> 00:13:32.975
our image of our brain
being a unique mosaic

00:13:32.985 --> 00:13:36.988
of male and female characteristics.

00:13:36.988 --> 00:13:39.380
I will close with this.

00:13:39.380 --> 00:13:43.930
Many people believe that
there are male brains and female brains,

00:13:43.930 --> 00:13:47.259
because this belief gives them
an explanation

00:13:47.259 --> 00:13:49.824
to why men and women are so different,

00:13:49.830 --> 00:13:54.510
and why they should behave differently
and be treated differently.

00:13:54.510 --> 00:13:57.032
I have shown you today
that it is meaningless

00:13:57.032 --> 00:13:59.417
to talk of the sex of the brain.

00:13:59.417 --> 00:14:02.678
Brains do not have sex.

00:14:02.702 --> 00:14:06.527
If you must relate to the brain's sex, 
you can call it intersex,

00:14:06.527 --> 00:14:09.550
a mixture of male
and female characteristics.

00:14:09.550 --> 00:14:13.725
There are no male brains
and no female brains.

00:14:13.725 --> 00:14:18.482
Therefore, their existence cannot explain
fundamental differences

00:14:18.482 --> 00:14:20.773
between men and women.

00:14:20.773 --> 00:14:23.828
Which is not really a big problem
considering the fact

00:14:23.853 --> 00:14:29.259
that men and women 
are remarkably similar.

00:14:29.259 --> 00:14:32.049
Be yourself.
(Laughter)

00:14:32.049 --> 00:14:32.920
Thank you.

00:14:32.920 --> 00:14:41.279
(Applause)