-
The Jewish Law Corner
-
We'll look at a few Jewish laws regarding muktzeh on Shabbat.
-
Many people ask whether they can touch a hammer or money on Shabbat.
-
They say, "I'm not buying anything. I just want to move my wallet from one place to another."
-
And in general there is confusion surrounding what we're allowed to touch on Shabbat
-
and what we're not allowed to touch on Shabbat (muktzeh).
-
So we need to clarify the issue. First of all, we're allowed to touch anything on Shabbat.
-
As long as we don't move it, there's no problem. You can touch a car, money, with your finger,
-
as long as you don't move the coin--just touching muktzeh is not prohibited.
-
The Shabbat prohibition only concerns moving something from one place to another.
-
There are several different categories of laws regarding muktzeh--several categories of objects.
-
Each category has its own laws. We must preface this by explaining that there are Shabbat prohibitions
-
that are from the Torah (d'Oraita), such as the prohibition of igniting a flame or plucking a leaf
-
or writing or drawing or sewing something, tearing something. All of these are Torah prohibitions.
-
A person who turns the key of his car ignition on Shabbat, he is igniting a flame.
-
Or turning on lights, or lighting a cigarette--all of these are equally severe:
-
They are Torah prohibitions.
-
Other prohibitions were added by our Sages, as part of the authority the Torah grants them.
-
"You shall safeguard My charge" [Lev.18:30]. Our Sages were given guidelines on how to
-
decree certain restrictions, as the Mishna says, "make a fence for the Torah" [Avot 1:1].
-
They must make a fence, a protective border. But they can't just decree whatever they want.
-
There are rules in the Torah about what they're allowed to decree, what they must not decree,
-
and we, the nation of Israel, are commanded:
-
"you shall not deviate from the word that they will tell you, right or left" [Deut.17:11].
-
Meaning, once our Sages--not from this generation, but in those generations,
-
once the Talmud was completed, and a spiritual decline was apparent, our Sages saw
-
that they no longer had the knowledge of how spiritual worlds are structured
-
in order to make rulings according to the necessary guidelines.
-
So they took upon themselves to refrain from making further rulings. But until the Talmud was completed,
-
they had the authority to make rulings, such as lighting Chanuka candles--which our Sages ruled--
-
but we make the blessing of:
-
"Who has sanctified us with His commandments, and has commanded us to kindle the Chanuka light"
-
Our Sages ask in the Talmud, "where is this commandment?"
-
After all, this is a ruling of our Sages. And the response is: we were commanded by
-
"you shall not deviate"--the Torah says:
-
"you shall not deviate from the word that they will tell you, right or left"--
-
so once we are so commanded not do deviate, it's as if a king commands me, "follow this man,
-
he'll show you what to do". It's an order from on high--whatever he says, you must do.
-
If he tells you to build a house, you're building it on my tab, I'll give you what's needed for it
-
according to the guidelines and instructions. So of course if a king commands this of you,
-
we are commanded by the king to listen to this man. So our Sages have their guidelines,
-
about how to make protective fences, and we are commanded not to deviate from their rulings.
-
And we're talking about our Sages from those generations.
-
One of their rulings was this concept of muktzeh--objects we are prohibited from moving on Shabbat.
-
This means that even though you're not igniting a flame, you're not tearing anything,
-
you haven't created anything, and all you did was move something from one place to another
-
not everything can be moved on Shabbat. Our Sages made this ruling for several reasons:
-
Someone fiddling with a hammer might happen to, meaning, if he were allowed to move a hammer
-
on Shabbat, could by-the-by happen to fix something with it, which means he'd transgress
-
a Torah prohibition.
-
Another reason for this ruling: the special Shabbat atmosphere.
-
Part of the special feeling of Shabbat comes when a person enters a spiritual atmosphere,
-
But if he's handling money, walking around with a wallet in his pocket,
-
moves all kinds of things around, he doesn't sufficiently enter the spiritual realm
-
of Shabbat. He's got 24 hours to disconnect himself from the radio, phone, TV, flame,
-
and he also doesn't handle money, tools, sewing implements, etc.
-
he is on a different spiritual plane, his whole Shabbat has a different feel to it,
-
he is elevated. Maimonides (Rambam) lists other reasons as well.
-
When we look at all the objects we own, they can be divided into several categories:
-
Our Sages determined rules for each category, for what is allowed & what is prohibited.
-
One category is called Utensils Whose Purpose is Permitted (kli shemelachto leheter).
-
With a Utensil Whose Purpose is Permitted, you can move it for any reason you want.
-
What are some examples of a Utensil Whose Purpose is Permitted? Silverware, for example.
-
Or furniture, or clothes. These are items meant for permitted use--to wear them,
-
to eat with them. Moving them on Shabbat is permitted, for any purpose.
-
The next category, in terms of severity, is
-
Utensils Whose Purpose is Prohibited (kli shemelachto leissur).
-
Utensils Whose Purpose is Prohibited, meaning any object that is a utensil,
-
meaning it's not just some stone in the street--stones are not a utensil--
-
branches, dirt, animals are not called utensils. But something that is a utensil,
-
meaning it has a specified purpose, such as sewing implements, writing utensils, tools--
-
these are utensils, but their use is prohibited. Unlike silverware, or plates and so on, whose use is allowed.
-
Their purpose is a prohibited act. A needle's purpose is sewing. A hammer, and so on--
-
Utensils Whose Purpose is Prohibited--must not be moved on Shabbat for a purpose other than
-
for Shabbat. If it's for Shabbat, for example, he has a coconut, and he wants to use a hammer
-
in order to crack it open. That is permitted on Shabbat. One is allowed to use a hammer
-
to crack open a coconut or any other nut. He doesn't have a nutcracker, and he wants to use a hammer.
-
It's permitted. But this is a Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited.
-
True, but even a Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited can be moved in order to use it
-
for an act permissible on Shabbat--such as using a hammer to crack open nuts.
-
Or it can be moved because one needs the place where the object lies. You want to sit on a chair,
-
and you see there is a saw on the seat. You need the seat. Or you sit by the table and you see
-
sewing implements on the table. One is allowed to pick them up by hand and put them in place.
-
You don't have to just toss them. Once you've lifted it for a permitted reason, because you need its place,
-
you can take it to wherever it belongs and put it in place.
-
This is called a Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited--it can be moved in order to use it
-
for a purpose permitted on Shabbat, or for the place upon which it lay.
-
But if it is not for a purpose permitted on Shabbat or for the place upon which it lay,
-
but just to move it out of the sun--he's worried the sun will ruin it--
-
and it's a Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited--he's concerned that, if it stays out in the yard,
-
rather than bringing it in to the house, it will get lost. Moving a Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited
-
on Shabbat is not permitted, unless it's to use it for Shabbat, or you need the place where it lay.
-
A Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited cannot be moved out of the sun. What he can do, for example,
-
if there's a hammer in the yard and he's afraid it will get stolen--and one is not allowed
-
to move the utensil to avoid theft, but he's worried someone will come into the yard
-
and steal his hammer. So he can, even though he didn't intend to eat nuts, he can decide to eat nuts.
-
He takes the nuts and then takes the hammer in order to crack them open. After using it
-
in the permissible way, he can put the hammer in place. And this is not considered
-
Prohibited Slyness (Ha'arama Asura). There are schemes that are prohibited, where we say,
-
"who are you trying to fool? What are you trying to pull?" But there are schemes that are
-
within permitted limits. It's not called slyness. So he decided now to eat nuts. He'll enjoy these nuts.
-
But in order to crack them open, he'll need the hammer. In this manner, it's permitted.
-
The next category up in terms of severity, is called in Jewish Law, Items That Have No Specific Purpose
-
(muktzeh mechamat gufo). As we said, the first category is Utensils Whose Purpose is Permitted--
-
anything intended for a permitted use on Shabbat--can be moved for any reason,
-
even if it's out in the yard. There's silverware out in the yard, and you're afraid it will get stolen.
-
You're allowed to bring them inside. A leather couch that the sun is beating down on--
-
you're worried the sun will ruin it--you're allowed to bring it in to the house, because it's a
-
Utensil Whose Purpose is Permitted. We saw that the category of Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited
-
is more severe. You can move it to use it for a permitted purpose or for its place
-
to use the place where it lay, but not to take it out of the sun. The next level in terms of severity
-
is called Items With No Specific Purpose. This kind of item is not considered a utensil.
-
It's not even a utensil. For example, stones, dirt, branches, animals--you have no use for an animal
-
on Shabbat. Someone raising different animals in his home--beavers, rabbits, chickens and chicks
-
and so on--all animals are considered Items With No Specific Purpose. You're allowed to pet it.
-
You're allowed to pet an animal, but you're not allowed to pick it up. Just like you're not allowed
-
to pick up stones on Shabbat. And someone who picks up stones on Shabbat is desecrating Shabbat.
-
Meaning, those who throw stones on cars driving past on Shabbat in the course of protests for Shabbat,
-
stones should be thrown on them, since THEY are actually desecrating Shabbat!
-
The stone itself is muktzeh--you're not allowed to move a stone on Shabbat.
-
Here we should note that, the truth is, that those who throw stones on Shabbat are people who don't have
-
even an ounce of Fear of Heaven. Anyone familiar with this issue knows that most great rabbis
-
oppose these protests. There are a few who support protesting in the streets where people
-
are desecrating Shabbat, others say that "his gain is offset by his loss" [Avos 5:14]--
-
nothing is gained from these protests. But even those who do call for protests always emphasize
-
in their announcements that violence must be avoided. And really, most of the protest,
-
as those present can attest, involves people standing around singing Shabbat songs,
-
walking around among their group. A cheeky young guy might show up and throw a stone
-
because he wants to see some commotion, and then policemen might ride up on horses,
-
and of course the nightly news won't show the three hours of peaceful protest,
-
but rather the few minutes of commotion. And then Israelis get the impression that,
-
what do haredi people do all day? They've got nothing better to do than throw stones.
-
It's a fact--we saw it on TV. Because that's their exposure to haredim.
-
Whereas, the truth is, the stone itself is muktzeh on Shabbat,
-
and someone who throws stones on Shabbat is himself desecrating Shabbat.
-
It's completely prohibited to move a stone on Shabbat. So stones, animals, branches, dirt--
-
as well as coins, bills--are not utensils, are not like tools, sewing implements.
-
They are classified as Items With No Specific Purpose.
-
Items With No Specific Purpose cannot be moved on Shabbat,
-
even for a use permitted on Shabbat, or for the place upon which they lie.
-
It's more severe than a Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited. Meaning, someone who wants
-
to crack open nuts on Shabbat is not allowed to take a stone and use it to crack open nuts.
-
A hammer can be used, because it is a utensil. But a stone--no. Unless, he took a rock
-
and made it into a utensil. How does he do this? Even if he changed nothing about the rock.
-
If he designates it for regular use--he found some rock he really likes--
-
and he wants to use it regularly as a nutcracker. Or, he took a rock and set it permanently by the door
-
in order to keep it open. There's a special item that does that. But he wants to save money,
-
so he didn't buy that item. He took a rock from the street, but it's permanently placed there,
-
to prevent the door from closing. So this rock itself has become a utensil. Once it has been thus defined,
-
because it is used regularly, the rock itself has become a utensil that is permitted on Shabbat.
-
Such a rock can be used as a nutcracker, etc. It's rare that a person uses a rock on a regular basis,
-
thereby turning it into a utensil. But, if he did so, it is now defined as a utensil.
-
There are of course many more details to these laws, and it's important to learn them.
-
In our Shabbat Laws cassette tape series, we went into greater detail about all these laws:
-
If it must be designated for eternity, or if it can be designated for a period of time,
-
but those are details and right now we're just going through the basic rules.
-
There is one more category of muktzeh, known as
-
Expensive Objects Used Only for a Specific Purpose (muktzeh mechamat chesron kis).
-
Meaning, a Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited on Shabbat, such as we discussed earlier
-
with the hammer, saw, etc.--these are Utensils Whose Purpose is Prohibited--
-
can be moved for a permitted use or for their place, but cannot be brought into the shade.
-
But, if the Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited is an item with which we take great care,
-
not to use it for anything other than its specific purpose, such as a mohel's knife--
-
used for brit milah. The mohel is very careful with this knife, and would never use it for anything else.
-
If he should ever want to cut paper, for example, he wouldn't use the brit milah knife.
-
It's an expensive knife. If, on Shabbat, he realizes he has nothing else, and
-
he wants to use the brit milah knife in order to cut something permitted,
-
he would not be allowed to use the brit milah knife. But why? We saw earlier
-
that a Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited can be moved in order to use it for a permitted purpose,
-
or for its place? The answer is, something you are careful not to use for anything other
-
than its intended purpose because of its great value, is defined as
-
an Expensive Object Used Only for a Specific Purpose. It rises to the next level of severity.
-
This is known as an Expensive Object Used Only for a Specific Purpose--
-
something we are careful not to use for anything other than its intended use.
-
An Expensive Object Used Only for a Specific Purpose cannot be used even
-
for a purpose permitted on Shabbat, and cannot be moved even if we need the place where it lies.
-
In summary, today we reviewed the four categories of muktzeh--objects that cannot be moved on Shabbat:
-
a Utensil Whose Purpose is Permitted, which can be moved on Shabbat for any reason,
-
including to bring it in to the shade, a Utensil Whose Purpose is Prohibited,
-
which is defined as a utensil, but whose intended purpose involves a Shabbat prohibition,
-
such as tools, sewing implements, etc.--can be moved in order to use it for a purpose permitted on Shabbat,
-
such as cracking nuts open, but cannot be brought into the shade. We also saw that
-
we can move it if we need its spot. The next level up was Items With No Specific Purpose--
-
which are not even defined as utensils--such as stones, animals, and so on.
-
Of course, the chicken on my plate can be moved, because it's food. But a live chicken
-
wandering around my yard--animals are defined as muktzeh, so I am allowed to pet them,
-
but I can't pick him up and move him. At home, too, I can't move him. The fourth category:
-
Expensive Objects Used Only for a Specific Purpose--an object that is intended for a prohibited use,
-
so it seems we could have moved it for a permitted use or for its spot, but since we are careful
-
not to use it for any other purpose, it is defined as something we are prohibited from moving altogether.
-
The word "muktzeh" comes from the root meaning "to designate".
-
Meaning, a person designates it out of his mind, takes his mind off it,
-
because he knows this is an object he will not be using on Shabbat.
-
We started this lecture by listing a few reasons for prohibiting the movement
-
of certain objects on Shabbat, and the manner in which it is prohibited. There are other reasons, too,
-
as listed by the Rambam (Maimonides) in his section on the Laws of Muktzeh.
-
translated by Onkelus Translations www.onkelus.com